In London the bombs didn't go off, in Egypt they did. The reports from Egypt are still too sketchy for me to have a clear picture, looks like a couple of car bombs plus a smaller one. One of the car bombs rammed into a hotel and blew up. It looks as if another car bomb went off right after a smaller bomb. This is an all-to-common M.O. a bomb to create an initial set of casualties then a bigger bomb to catch the rescue and security people. No definitive idea of who did it yet but I'd be willing to bet next week's grocery money that it wasn't a bunch of angry Lutherans. Maybe the Methodists?
I've a somewhat better picture of London. Seems that our brethren from the Religion of Pieces screwed the pooch. The explosive used, something called TATP is very unstable and difficult to store. If the TATP was left over from the 7/7 bombings it could easily have degraded in two weeks. It's also fairly easy to screw up the mixture, I'm told. At any rate the forensic people have a treasure trove of evidence now. That's good news. Forensics isn't my baliwick, I have a pretty good idea how to preserve a scene for others to process but I know enough to believe that evidence that didn't explode is more likely to be immediately useful than evidence that did explode. The security and intel people are going to learn a lot, how much they will, or should, share with the public is another question.
This much is generally known about TATP. It's made from widely available ingredients, ingredients that will raise no eyebrows if bought in nominal quantities. A small number of people each going to different stores can easily amass enough to make several very loud noises. Also on the plus side (from the spodeydope's point of view) is that the mixing it up, while quite dangerous, is fairly simple. I guess if one is planning on wearing it when it explodes, the risk in mixing it and making the bomb itself, once the explosive is made, is acceptable. Also on the plus side of the ledger for the splodeydope is that it's very difficult for the bomb dogs and explosive sniffer machines to detect. Keep this known fact in mind, it's the source of much that follows.
On the minus side of the ledger is that the stuff often makes the loud noise before the splodeydope intends it to.Those one-handed, or no handed 'clerics' and blind sheikhs weren't born that way. We could probably make a pretty good dent in the splodeydope population with a simple policy of shooting Muslims with blown-off or badly burned body parts on sight. 'Course we'd blow away a few who were just unlucky enough to have been in other sorts of accidents but it seems to make more sense to me than strip searching Norwegian Grandmothers. We saw the results of the other downside to TATP in the bombs that fizzled.
I'm sure the rational behind the searches of bags and backpacks in New York City, for instance, is a direct result of the difficulty the dogs and 'sniffers' have in detecting this stuff. Michelle Malkin linked to an article that explains just about everything it is safe to about TAPT. It's a website called Hyscience. I've bookmarked it and shall poke around some more in it. Lot of smart people out there.
I'm most gratified to see how the armed Police Officers took down that feller in the bulky coat yesterday. It seems that he didn't have a bomb, I'm wondering if he was simply stupid or a decoy. It's one or the other. Here's the deal. If the police think that they've a suicide bomber there's only one way for that suspect to avoid being shot full of holes, that's stop, show empty hands and follow instructions to the letter. You know that remote for your car door locks? How long does it take to work it? That's how long it takes to set off a bomb.
Imagine that you are wearing a badge and gun. You are close enough to that suspect for him to give you a Very Bad Day. There are also a bunch of civilians around and it's been drilled into your head since the Academy that it's your duty to protect them. Are you going to jackass around with him? Maybe get into a rasslin' match? Will anyone stand over your grave and admire your committment to civil liberties?
The splodeydope is causing a shift in the policies of police and security agencies. It is considered bad form for Officers to blow a suspect away without giving multiple chances to surrender, even to the point where there are serious complaints if the bad guy doesn't get the first shot in, often complaints when he does get the first shot. I'm thinking of that scumbag in LA that wounded a bluesuit while holding his baby daughter. The death of that baby was, and is, a tragedy. I know damned well that those Officers involved will go to their graves hating it. Thing is, it wasn't the fault of the Officers. Just what were they supposed to do with one of their own bleeding on the ground? The shame is that it happened fast enough to where they couldn't have one of their scoped rifle guys put that scumbag out of our misery with a nice clean headshot.
With the splodeydopes, all that has to go out the window. An Officer will have just one split second chance to stop the bomb from going off, if we get that chance at all.The onus MUST be on the suspect to stop, show empty hands and comply with all instructions. Period. There can be no confusion about this.
Here's a personal opinion about our policies. I think that it's madness to go around searching those afore-mentioned Norwegian Grandmothers while avoiding 'racial profiling'. We have a pretty good idea of who these splodeydopes are and they ain't Norwegian Grandmaws. There is only one thing stupider than that policy, those "I do not consent to being searched" shirts. It's pretty much a given that we all agree that it's only a matter of time before the splodeydopes start blowing up here. The argument between Left and Right isn't about "if". It's about why and whom to blame.
It's just a matter of time, too, before someoneon the Right, or the Left, decides to be a civil-liberties hee-row and wear a big coat in August, maybe along with a backpack with protruding wires and loudly proclaim his 'rights'. Good luck. Maybe all you'll get are those rights. and a few lefts, too. Don't try running, m'kay? Remember those five head shots.
I'm no fonder than anyone else about the idea of some stranger pawing through my stuff. I feel so strongly about it that I deliberately avoid, whenever possible, going where it's likely that some stranger would have occassion to do so. I'm less fond, though, of seeing body parts srewn haphazardly about wreckage. Been there. Done that. Got the vomit stained T-shirt.
It's a new era, our Police and security forces don't like it any better than anyone else. The dangers we're facing are real, not imagined. We'd cut down considerably on those dangers if Left and Right would agree to argue about taxes and welfare reform and present a united front about national security. Somehow I believe it would be far easier to solve, say, social security if as few as possible of us are blown up.
Saturday, July 23, 2005
Carnival of the Cordite #23
The Carnival of the Cordite is up at But That's Just My Opinion.
Lot's of gunny goodness and an important WARNING TO HANDLOADERS. Seems that a batch of Alliant's Bullseye smokeless powder got put into the wrong eight pound cannisters. A small number (?) of eight pound cannisters of Unique Powder actually contain Bull. Using Unique data for Bull can easily result in a KABOOM! Lot numbers involved are 850, 859, 861, 868, 872, 876, 890, 898 and 907. Anyone having any of the eight pound cannisters of these lots should call 1-800-276-9337 or E-mail: reloading@alliantpowders.com. Thank you Mr. Completely. Those of you who have no idea what lot numbers are nor what Unique and Bullseye are, well, you don't handload ammo so don't worry about it. Unless, of course, you shoot commercially reloaded ammo. If you do, it might not hurt to make contact with the outfit that made those reloads and ask them if they're involved in that recall. The smaller commercial reloaders do use the eight pound cannisters, the really big outfits buy their powder by the drum. Of course the factories buy it by the boxcar load.
Lot's of gunny goodness and an important WARNING TO HANDLOADERS. Seems that a batch of Alliant's Bullseye smokeless powder got put into the wrong eight pound cannisters. A small number (?) of eight pound cannisters of Unique Powder actually contain Bull. Using Unique data for Bull can easily result in a KABOOM! Lot numbers involved are 850, 859, 861, 868, 872, 876, 890, 898 and 907. Anyone having any of the eight pound cannisters of these lots should call 1-800-276-9337 or E-mail: reloading@alliantpowders.com. Thank you Mr. Completely. Those of you who have no idea what lot numbers are nor what Unique and Bullseye are, well, you don't handload ammo so don't worry about it. Unless, of course, you shoot commercially reloaded ammo. If you do, it might not hurt to make contact with the outfit that made those reloads and ask them if they're involved in that recall. The smaller commercial reloaders do use the eight pound cannisters, the really big outfits buy their powder by the drum. Of course the factories buy it by the boxcar load.
Thursday, July 21, 2005
The First Step In Handloading
We've gone over all the components of the cartridge, now it's time to think about assembling them into functional ammunition. The very first step is not to run out and spend a buttload of money buying equipment and components, though. Step one is to think about the following questions...
Am I able to follow simple directions without getting big ideas on "improving" them before I even know what I'm doing? It's my belief that anyone who can follow a simple recipe out of a cookbook and make a decent meal from it can handload safe and functional ammunition,
Is my lifestyle such that it is safe for me to have powder, primers and suchlike around? Will my kids, or stoned roommate stay out of my stuff? If not, is there a way to keep them out of it?
If the answer to both these questions is "yes" then every other difficulty can be solved, beginning with: Do I have space to work? Space for storage?
The next question is: What am I trying to accomplish with my handloads? Here I should explode the myth that handloading saves money. No one in history has ever saved a nickel handloading, we just shoot a lot more for the same money. At least it's the same money until we get one of the many derangements possible and find ourselves spending the house payment on that latest wonder bullet or shiny new toy.
We need to decide what we're trying to accomplish with our handloading before we buy the first piece of equipment. The best loading press, for making large quantities of inexpensive ammunition is not the best press for the guy, or gal, who wants to make ammunition for the top level of many of the various competitions.
What level of equipment can I afford? Do I know someone who can help me buy used and not get burned? If I do, will they help me get started? It's easier to learn anything if we have a mentor, a hands-on mentor makes it easiest of all but that mentor can also be in print or even on-line.
I'm going to work off a few assumptions in this series, they are as follows...
Golden Assumption: You aren't a chuckleheaded moron. All chuckleheaded morons should leave this site and not come back.
Assumption #1: Your goal in handloading is to get a sufficient quantity of affordable ammo that you can really shoot enough to really get good.
Assumption #2: You have a limited budget.
Assumption #3: You don't have a large workshop to devote solely to handloading.
Assumption #4: you'll be loading primarily handgun ammunition.
With those assumptions in mind, let's walk through our house or apartment. It's probably not a good idea for the homeless to try to set up their own little ammo factory. What we are looking for is space to set up a sturdy desk, table or bench. There should be room for a bookshelf or cabinet nearby for storage of components and equipment. This area doesn't have to be huge although as we go along we'll gather more and more stuff. What is imperative is that it be a low-traffic area. We can't leave our stuff where just anyone can mess with it, nor is it a good idea to try to load ammunition where there are a lot of distractions.
It is best if our bench, table or desk is used for nothing but loading, this is not always possible. If it isn't possible it's not an insurmountable problem, it's just a minor pain in the kazoo. We have to set our gear up and take it down every session.
In my opinion it is a mistake to permanently mount one's press to the bench. It's fine to do so if we have the luxury of a spacious bench and room that is used for nothing but reloading. I don't have that luxury of space, I may want to use my 'bench' an old schoolteacher's desk, for my turret press one day, my big, and expensive, Forster Bonanza Co-ax press the next, take everything off and clean guns, or set up my casting furnace and cast a thousand or so bullets.
Instead of mounting my gear directly to the bench, it's all mounted on pieces of plank ends scrounged from construction sites. Just go by a building site with a sixpack of cold cokes on a hot day and ask nicely if they've got some two by ten or twelve plank ends and you'll get more than you'll ever need. Each of my presses is mounted to the plank end and then C-clamped on the bench as needed.
Our very first purchase should NOT be a loading press or bench or anything of the sort. It should be a GOOD loading manual, preferably more than one. We should also take advantage of the library and even the 'net. Look on my sidebar, click Midway and go to the section on books and manuals. The Speer Manual is good, so are the Hornaday and Sierra Manuals. Anyone interested in handloading needs to have at least one of these, all three is better. Sit down and read the "how to" sections. Let the information settle in and then re-read them. Another good one is Dick Lee's Modern Reloading.
Be warned, here, all of the people writing for these manuals are in cahoots with a specific company For instance, reading the Speer manual will leave the impression that only Speer bullets, CCI Primers and RCBS loading tools will suffice. Now, RCBS loading tools are mostly pretty durned good and they've a warranty second to none. Yet any one piece of their equipment may not be the best for my purposes.
There are three types of bench mounted loading presses, the single stage, having only one station for the die and shellholder. The turret press has more than one die station but only one shellholder. The progressive press has a die station and shellholder for each different step of the process, the shellholders advance the cartridge case through each die.
The beginning handloader should, in my opinion, steer clear of the progressive presses. When the equipment is doing every step of the loading process at once it adds to the complexity and chances for error. An error in handloading can result in a destroyed gun and injury, or even death, to shooter or bystanders.
I'm not real fond of loading handgun ammo on a single stage press, either. Since I usually load one box of fifty at a time and a shooting session generally involves a minimum of three hundred rounds it's a pain switching dies every few minutes. A turret press eliminates that problem. Mike Dillon hadn't made the big breakthrough in progressive reloading presses by the time I retired from formal competition. I managed to keep a job as well as fire some thousand rounds per week to stay at the top of my game with a turret press. I even managed to spend ten minutes or so a month with the family.
Depending on the depths of your pocket, there are several good turret presses to choose from. The least expensive is the Lee. With the exception of a clunky, user unfriendly priming system the Lee is a good, serviceable press, I still load handgun ammo on one. The priming system doesn't bother me, I haven't primed a case in a press for decades anyhow. We'll discus that in more detail later in this series. I especially like the Lee setup with the powder through expander die where we drop the powder charge at the same time we bell the casemouth. The Lee Auto-disc powder measure is so inexpensive that I just use one per cartridge that I load and leave each turret set up. It takes less than thirty seconds to pop a shell holder and turret into the press to switch from, say .357 Magnum to .45 Colt.
The Lyman T-Mag press is a good one, I've never owned one but I've worked a couple belonging to friends. What I don't like about the Lyman is that it's difficult to change turrets. I like having my dies set up in spare turrets so I don't have to be constantly re-adjusting them. Still, if one only loads a couple of different cartridges, it's not a big deal. The Lyman runs about sixty bucks higher than does the Lee.
Next up in price is the RCBS. It's a very good press and the warranty is quite simple, if it breaks, they fix it or replace it. It's got a removable turret and the turrets are easily exchanged. If your wallet can stand the gaff, the RCBS is a darned good choice.
The Rolls Royce of turret presses just has to be the Redding. I've loaded ammo on a pal's Redding T-7 and it was a pleasure. If my paychecks had to be delivered by forklift, I'd own one.
Go over to the sidebar, click on Midway's site and poke around the metallic loading presses. Read the customer reviews, count your dollars and decide. Bear this in mind, though. There is NO difference in the quality of ammunition we can produce on a sixty dollar Lee press and a two hundred dollar Redding. I will go so far as to say that ninety percent of beginning handgun ammo loaders would be best served by the less expensive Lee. That is because some of you will decide handloading isn't your cup pf tea. More will like it but decide they want more speed and go to a progressive press once they've had sufficient hands-on experience. The value of a press on the used market is about the same as used toilet paper. It simply makes no sense to buy the most expensive press on the market if, in six months, one will spend three hundred or more dollars buying a Dillon Progressive.
Whichever brand you decide to go with be sure and buy the die set with the carbide sizing die for straight walled handgun cases. We don't need to be spending the time lubing cases and then cleaning the lube off the loaded rounds.
Look long and hard at the "complete" kits for one cartridge. I put complete in quotes because there is no such thing as a complete kit. I am aware of no kit that comes with everything we need. Some come with almost everything. Buy the RCBS, for instance and you get everything but the loading dies ands a case trimmer. Buy the Lee, you get the dies but no powder measure or case trimmer. Sigh. We'll talk about case trimmers next week when we discuss case inspection, preparation and sizing.
Am I able to follow simple directions without getting big ideas on "improving" them before I even know what I'm doing? It's my belief that anyone who can follow a simple recipe out of a cookbook and make a decent meal from it can handload safe and functional ammunition,
Is my lifestyle such that it is safe for me to have powder, primers and suchlike around? Will my kids, or stoned roommate stay out of my stuff? If not, is there a way to keep them out of it?
If the answer to both these questions is "yes" then every other difficulty can be solved, beginning with: Do I have space to work? Space for storage?
The next question is: What am I trying to accomplish with my handloads? Here I should explode the myth that handloading saves money. No one in history has ever saved a nickel handloading, we just shoot a lot more for the same money. At least it's the same money until we get one of the many derangements possible and find ourselves spending the house payment on that latest wonder bullet or shiny new toy.
We need to decide what we're trying to accomplish with our handloading before we buy the first piece of equipment. The best loading press, for making large quantities of inexpensive ammunition is not the best press for the guy, or gal, who wants to make ammunition for the top level of many of the various competitions.
What level of equipment can I afford? Do I know someone who can help me buy used and not get burned? If I do, will they help me get started? It's easier to learn anything if we have a mentor, a hands-on mentor makes it easiest of all but that mentor can also be in print or even on-line.
I'm going to work off a few assumptions in this series, they are as follows...
Golden Assumption: You aren't a chuckleheaded moron. All chuckleheaded morons should leave this site and not come back.
Assumption #1: Your goal in handloading is to get a sufficient quantity of affordable ammo that you can really shoot enough to really get good.
Assumption #2: You have a limited budget.
Assumption #3: You don't have a large workshop to devote solely to handloading.
Assumption #4: you'll be loading primarily handgun ammunition.
With those assumptions in mind, let's walk through our house or apartment. It's probably not a good idea for the homeless to try to set up their own little ammo factory. What we are looking for is space to set up a sturdy desk, table or bench. There should be room for a bookshelf or cabinet nearby for storage of components and equipment. This area doesn't have to be huge although as we go along we'll gather more and more stuff. What is imperative is that it be a low-traffic area. We can't leave our stuff where just anyone can mess with it, nor is it a good idea to try to load ammunition where there are a lot of distractions.
It is best if our bench, table or desk is used for nothing but loading, this is not always possible. If it isn't possible it's not an insurmountable problem, it's just a minor pain in the kazoo. We have to set our gear up and take it down every session.
In my opinion it is a mistake to permanently mount one's press to the bench. It's fine to do so if we have the luxury of a spacious bench and room that is used for nothing but reloading. I don't have that luxury of space, I may want to use my 'bench' an old schoolteacher's desk, for my turret press one day, my big, and expensive, Forster Bonanza Co-ax press the next, take everything off and clean guns, or set up my casting furnace and cast a thousand or so bullets.
Instead of mounting my gear directly to the bench, it's all mounted on pieces of plank ends scrounged from construction sites. Just go by a building site with a sixpack of cold cokes on a hot day and ask nicely if they've got some two by ten or twelve plank ends and you'll get more than you'll ever need. Each of my presses is mounted to the plank end and then C-clamped on the bench as needed.
Our very first purchase should NOT be a loading press or bench or anything of the sort. It should be a GOOD loading manual, preferably more than one. We should also take advantage of the library and even the 'net. Look on my sidebar, click Midway and go to the section on books and manuals. The Speer Manual is good, so are the Hornaday and Sierra Manuals. Anyone interested in handloading needs to have at least one of these, all three is better. Sit down and read the "how to" sections. Let the information settle in and then re-read them. Another good one is Dick Lee's Modern Reloading.
Be warned, here, all of the people writing for these manuals are in cahoots with a specific company For instance, reading the Speer manual will leave the impression that only Speer bullets, CCI Primers and RCBS loading tools will suffice. Now, RCBS loading tools are mostly pretty durned good and they've a warranty second to none. Yet any one piece of their equipment may not be the best for my purposes.
There are three types of bench mounted loading presses, the single stage, having only one station for the die and shellholder. The turret press has more than one die station but only one shellholder. The progressive press has a die station and shellholder for each different step of the process, the shellholders advance the cartridge case through each die.
The beginning handloader should, in my opinion, steer clear of the progressive presses. When the equipment is doing every step of the loading process at once it adds to the complexity and chances for error. An error in handloading can result in a destroyed gun and injury, or even death, to shooter or bystanders.
I'm not real fond of loading handgun ammo on a single stage press, either. Since I usually load one box of fifty at a time and a shooting session generally involves a minimum of three hundred rounds it's a pain switching dies every few minutes. A turret press eliminates that problem. Mike Dillon hadn't made the big breakthrough in progressive reloading presses by the time I retired from formal competition. I managed to keep a job as well as fire some thousand rounds per week to stay at the top of my game with a turret press. I even managed to spend ten minutes or so a month with the family.
Depending on the depths of your pocket, there are several good turret presses to choose from. The least expensive is the Lee. With the exception of a clunky, user unfriendly priming system the Lee is a good, serviceable press, I still load handgun ammo on one. The priming system doesn't bother me, I haven't primed a case in a press for decades anyhow. We'll discus that in more detail later in this series. I especially like the Lee setup with the powder through expander die where we drop the powder charge at the same time we bell the casemouth. The Lee Auto-disc powder measure is so inexpensive that I just use one per cartridge that I load and leave each turret set up. It takes less than thirty seconds to pop a shell holder and turret into the press to switch from, say .357 Magnum to .45 Colt.
The Lyman T-Mag press is a good one, I've never owned one but I've worked a couple belonging to friends. What I don't like about the Lyman is that it's difficult to change turrets. I like having my dies set up in spare turrets so I don't have to be constantly re-adjusting them. Still, if one only loads a couple of different cartridges, it's not a big deal. The Lyman runs about sixty bucks higher than does the Lee.
Next up in price is the RCBS. It's a very good press and the warranty is quite simple, if it breaks, they fix it or replace it. It's got a removable turret and the turrets are easily exchanged. If your wallet can stand the gaff, the RCBS is a darned good choice.
The Rolls Royce of turret presses just has to be the Redding. I've loaded ammo on a pal's Redding T-7 and it was a pleasure. If my paychecks had to be delivered by forklift, I'd own one.
Go over to the sidebar, click on Midway's site and poke around the metallic loading presses. Read the customer reviews, count your dollars and decide. Bear this in mind, though. There is NO difference in the quality of ammunition we can produce on a sixty dollar Lee press and a two hundred dollar Redding. I will go so far as to say that ninety percent of beginning handgun ammo loaders would be best served by the less expensive Lee. That is because some of you will decide handloading isn't your cup pf tea. More will like it but decide they want more speed and go to a progressive press once they've had sufficient hands-on experience. The value of a press on the used market is about the same as used toilet paper. It simply makes no sense to buy the most expensive press on the market if, in six months, one will spend three hundred or more dollars buying a Dillon Progressive.
Whichever brand you decide to go with be sure and buy the die set with the carbide sizing die for straight walled handgun cases. We don't need to be spending the time lubing cases and then cleaning the lube off the loaded rounds.
Look long and hard at the "complete" kits for one cartridge. I put complete in quotes because there is no such thing as a complete kit. I am aware of no kit that comes with everything we need. Some come with almost everything. Buy the RCBS, for instance and you get everything but the loading dies ands a case trimmer. Buy the Lee, you get the dies but no powder measure or case trimmer. Sigh. We'll talk about case trimmers next week when we discuss case inspection, preparation and sizing.
More London Explosions
Another four(?) explosions in London this morning, the reports are too scattered and confused yet to make much sense of it. So far, though, no serious casualties reported.
I'll be working today on my entry for Carnival of the Cordite so won't be adding my ignorance to the babble about London until a day or so later, when I have some idea of what happened. The big news blogs are all over it, anyway. See Michelle Malkin or the Puppy Blender for links.
I'll be working today on my entry for Carnival of the Cordite so won't be adding my ignorance to the babble about London until a day or so later, when I have some idea of what happened. The big news blogs are all over it, anyway. See Michelle Malkin or the Puppy Blender for links.
Wednesday, July 20, 2005
Note To Self
Try to remember that if you have a paper cut on a finger, to put a Bandaid on that cut before pouring Black Powder. The mix of sulfur, saltpeter and charcoal doesn't seem to be much fun when a granule gets stuck into the cut.
That is all.
That is all.
Tuesday, July 19, 2005
Another Fatwah From The Fatheads
In a rather interesting development it seems that some of our brethren from the Religion Of Pieces have declared a Fatwah demanding the killing of fellow Carnival of the Cordite contributor Chris in Phoenix. His Blog is titled Anarchangel.
The link, assuming I can get it right is here.
I've been following this a little and there seems to be a few different schools of thought. My friend Gullyborg, whom I've yet to meet in person, is taking this seriously. You can read his reaction here.
There seems to be another school of thought that this is a hoax. I don't believe that is the case, after all, a hoax would have a pretty short shelf life and, when exposed, would completely discredit Chris, probably forever. There is the possibility, of course, that the fatheads issuing this fatwah have neither the authority to do so nor means to carry it out. I wouldn't bet the farm on that, though It seems like just about the only requirement for the issuing of fatwahs is that some moose-limb has a grievance. I'm told that there is a minimum number of goats molested before one gathers the authority to issue fatwahs but I may be wrong there.
The third school of thought seems to be that Chris brought it on himself by desecrating a q'ran. I'm not inclined to either capitalize nor call it holy. From what I've seen Chris decided, when that phony Newsweak story about q'ran desecration in Gitmo came out, to show them some REAL desecration. At the time I thought it was kind of juvenile, but that's just me. Chris is fairly young anyway and one kind of expects that young folks would do juvenile things.
What I don't get is how these moose-limbs seem to think that it's fine for them to issue dire threats, and carry them out, every time their precious little sensibilities are offended. Every time I see the news, some moose-limb is offending me. I don't go 'round killing them, though I've certainly got the ability. I'd probably run up quite a little score before I was stopped, and not by the moose-limbs, either. We aren't at the point where ordinary citizens have to start a moose-limb eradication project, it is my hope that we won't reach that point.
I read an interesting piece by Lee Harris in Tech Central Station last week. Unfortunately I can't find the link, due to my well known status as one who is severely html challenged. In it, he declares that the "war" status is, perhaps, the wrong way to look at the fight between western civilization, or what's left of it, and radical Islam. Instead it's more a matter of a blood feud, a Hatfield and McCoy sort of affair. Or maybe the Crips and the Bloods. If anyone reading this (all three of you) can find that link and put it in the comments, I'd owe them one.
This may be an important distinction since the participants in a war usually have some idea of what they're trying to accomplish and will stop when they've reached their goals or figure out that they can't. Assume, for a moment, that I were King. No, don't curl up in a fetal position, it ain't gonna happen, just go with me here. I'm the King and I want to invade Mexico so I can control the Tequila Mines of the fabled city of Cuervo. The Mexicans defeat my army short of that goal and defend the Tequila Mine so well that my generals tell me that we'll never get there. Since the goal of my war is unattainable, I sue for peace and the war ends. The other alternative is that I win and Mexico sues for peace and learns to live without those fabulous Tequila Mines. One way or the other, the war is over.
Not so with a blood feud. There is only one goal in a blood feud, revenge. Each side has, as it's only goal, the killing of the other clan. A clan member doesn't have to be doing anything to be a target, he or she just has to be. Each attack adds to the feud and it usually goes on until one or the other clans is killed out. There's not a whole lot of possibility for peace because there are no goals but killing. The only way, short of death of one side or the other, to end a blood feud is for the moderate members of both clans to cast out the feudists. Failing that, the moderates must pick up the gun for, if they don't, they die.
Lee Harris' scenario is quite bleak. We so no effort whatsoever of moderate moose-limbs to cast out their feudists. This bodes ill for the moose-limbs for while their feudists are certainly bloodthirsty, they're amateurs when it comes to killing. It bodes especially ill for moose-limbs here in America, not only aren't they paricularly good at killing but they are a small and visible minority. The vast majority of Americans, myself included, have no hate for Islam and no particular love, either. What we do love are our friends and families, and our country. As long as Islam left us alone we were, and are, quite content to leave them be. Endanger my family, though and I'll do whatever it takes to stop you. If it were some of the Bloods threatening threatening my family and I didn't know which ones, everybody flying the red colors would be my enemies. And my targets.
This is the problem that the oft-heard of but seldom seen moderate Muslims face. The clock is ticking. Either they cast out their killers or, eventually, it will be too dangerous to let them live among us. When that day comes, if it comes, it would be well to understand that today's world is one where "among us" means on this planet.
UPDATE: 07/20/05. Please note that Harvey, the original Bad Example, found the link to the Lee Harris article. It's in the comments, the second one. Whether one agrees, or disagrees, it's an important piece and should be considered very carefully. While there is no one I agree with a hundred percent of the time, Harris has a first rate mind and a very good eye.
The link, assuming I can get it right is here.
I've been following this a little and there seems to be a few different schools of thought. My friend Gullyborg, whom I've yet to meet in person, is taking this seriously. You can read his reaction here.
There seems to be another school of thought that this is a hoax. I don't believe that is the case, after all, a hoax would have a pretty short shelf life and, when exposed, would completely discredit Chris, probably forever. There is the possibility, of course, that the fatheads issuing this fatwah have neither the authority to do so nor means to carry it out. I wouldn't bet the farm on that, though It seems like just about the only requirement for the issuing of fatwahs is that some moose-limb has a grievance. I'm told that there is a minimum number of goats molested before one gathers the authority to issue fatwahs but I may be wrong there.
The third school of thought seems to be that Chris brought it on himself by desecrating a q'ran. I'm not inclined to either capitalize nor call it holy. From what I've seen Chris decided, when that phony Newsweak story about q'ran desecration in Gitmo came out, to show them some REAL desecration. At the time I thought it was kind of juvenile, but that's just me. Chris is fairly young anyway and one kind of expects that young folks would do juvenile things.
What I don't get is how these moose-limbs seem to think that it's fine for them to issue dire threats, and carry them out, every time their precious little sensibilities are offended. Every time I see the news, some moose-limb is offending me. I don't go 'round killing them, though I've certainly got the ability. I'd probably run up quite a little score before I was stopped, and not by the moose-limbs, either. We aren't at the point where ordinary citizens have to start a moose-limb eradication project, it is my hope that we won't reach that point.
I read an interesting piece by Lee Harris in Tech Central Station last week. Unfortunately I can't find the link, due to my well known status as one who is severely html challenged. In it, he declares that the "war" status is, perhaps, the wrong way to look at the fight between western civilization, or what's left of it, and radical Islam. Instead it's more a matter of a blood feud, a Hatfield and McCoy sort of affair. Or maybe the Crips and the Bloods. If anyone reading this (all three of you) can find that link and put it in the comments, I'd owe them one.
This may be an important distinction since the participants in a war usually have some idea of what they're trying to accomplish and will stop when they've reached their goals or figure out that they can't. Assume, for a moment, that I were King. No, don't curl up in a fetal position, it ain't gonna happen, just go with me here. I'm the King and I want to invade Mexico so I can control the Tequila Mines of the fabled city of Cuervo. The Mexicans defeat my army short of that goal and defend the Tequila Mine so well that my generals tell me that we'll never get there. Since the goal of my war is unattainable, I sue for peace and the war ends. The other alternative is that I win and Mexico sues for peace and learns to live without those fabulous Tequila Mines. One way or the other, the war is over.
Not so with a blood feud. There is only one goal in a blood feud, revenge. Each side has, as it's only goal, the killing of the other clan. A clan member doesn't have to be doing anything to be a target, he or she just has to be. Each attack adds to the feud and it usually goes on until one or the other clans is killed out. There's not a whole lot of possibility for peace because there are no goals but killing. The only way, short of death of one side or the other, to end a blood feud is for the moderate members of both clans to cast out the feudists. Failing that, the moderates must pick up the gun for, if they don't, they die.
Lee Harris' scenario is quite bleak. We so no effort whatsoever of moderate moose-limbs to cast out their feudists. This bodes ill for the moose-limbs for while their feudists are certainly bloodthirsty, they're amateurs when it comes to killing. It bodes especially ill for moose-limbs here in America, not only aren't they paricularly good at killing but they are a small and visible minority. The vast majority of Americans, myself included, have no hate for Islam and no particular love, either. What we do love are our friends and families, and our country. As long as Islam left us alone we were, and are, quite content to leave them be. Endanger my family, though and I'll do whatever it takes to stop you. If it were some of the Bloods threatening threatening my family and I didn't know which ones, everybody flying the red colors would be my enemies. And my targets.
This is the problem that the oft-heard of but seldom seen moderate Muslims face. The clock is ticking. Either they cast out their killers or, eventually, it will be too dangerous to let them live among us. When that day comes, if it comes, it would be well to understand that today's world is one where "among us" means on this planet.
UPDATE: 07/20/05. Please note that Harvey, the original Bad Example, found the link to the Lee Harris article. It's in the comments, the second one. Whether one agrees, or disagrees, it's an important piece and should be considered very carefully. While there is no one I agree with a hundred percent of the time, Harris has a first rate mind and a very good eye.
Saturday, July 16, 2005
Carnival of the Codite #22
The Carnival of the Cordite is up, this week at Baboon Pirates. Please don't ask me about the name.
Thursday, July 14, 2005
Primers, The Spark Plug Of The Cartridge.
The centerfire rifle and handgun primers are intricate and interesting little beasts. There are five different types available, Small Pistol, Large Pistol, Small Rifle, large rifle and .50 Browning Machine Gun. In the first four are also standard and magnum. The only difference between standard and magnum primers is that the flame from the magnum primer can be somewhat hotter and lasts a couple of gazillionths of a second longer. This helps in the ignition of large charges of powder, especially the ball powders which are coated with chemicals to retard burning. I know, coating the powder with something to keep it from burning seems counterintuitive but that's how they control the burning rates.
Large rifle and pistol primers measure .210 inch across, while small rifle and pistol primers measure .175.
An interesting historical fact is that two different people on opposite sides of the Atlantic Ocean invented the metallic centerfire primer at about the same time. The American,Hiram Berdan, invented a primer that require the anvil (more on what the anvil is and does in a minute) to be part of the cartridge case, eliminating the possibility of one central flash hole.
At the same about time a British Ordnance Officer, Edward Boxer, invented a primer that had an integral anvil. This made primer manufacture a little more complicated but simplified cartridge case manufacture. It also made handloading quite a bit easier,
In an interesting twist, the Berdan Primer, invented in America, is used in Europe and Britain while the Boxer Primer, invented in Britain, is used in the USA. This is primarily because the reloading of cartridges was very rare in Europe while very common in the US. Berdan primed cases are a major pain to try to reload. There are only two ways to decap a Berdan primed case, there is a decapping tool that like an old fashioned can opener, punches a hole in the primer and the handloader prys the cap out by using that hole. This, um, sort of works. Then there's the hydraulic method. Fill the case with water, put a tight-fitting rod in and rap it with a hammer. Water squirts everywhere and, after enough tries, the primer is pushed out. Do not try this outside in Wisconsin in the dead of winter. With it's central flash hole the Boxer primed case is easy to decap, a decapping pin in the sizing die pops it right out. Back in the day, a lot of foreign cartridges were only available in Berdan priming. Those cartridges were also expensive and hard to find. I've reloaded some of those, I hope to never do so again. Thanks to the size of the American market, even European companies like Norma, Sellior and Benoit and Lapua have shifted to Boxer priming.
If it weren't for handloading the Berdan priming system would be superior. The small size of the individual parts of a primer means that the fewer parts, the better. The two, or even three, flash holes in a Berdan primed case can make for more consistent and reliable ignition. It's not worth the hassle to the handloader, though.
The Boxer Primer is built from several different parts. First is the cup, that's the outside of the primer, a stamping of thin, fairly soft metal, usually brass, that contains everything else. Next is a very small amount of explosive. This explosive has changed over the generations. The first used was Mercury Fulminate. This was very effective with Black Powder. When smokeless came along the shooters of the day discovered discovered a major problem, the mercury attacked the brass of the cartridge case. Black powder left so much residue behind that it diluted that mercury so much that it was harmless.
The ammomakers searched for a replacement and found Potassium Chorate. The drawback to the Potassium Chlorate is that it leaves Potassium Chloride, chemically very much like salt, behind. This salt is hygroscopic, meaning it attracts moisture. This causes rust. In the old days this didn't matter, shooters were used to black powder the residue of that is just as prone to cause rust. As the memory of black powder faded shooters stopped cleaning their shootin' irons with soap and water. The solvents and oils used did nothing to wash that salt out of the barrel and shooters wondered why their barrels rusted. Meanwhile, military shooters knew to use water and their bores remained in good shape. American military ammunition continued using these primers up into the 1950s as they had to be concerned with long storage. As a youngster I shot a lot of surplus ammunition with such priming. My WW2 veteran mentors taught me exactly how to prevent rust along with stories of what did when water was short. In my youthful imagination I envisioned some eight million soldiers all peeing down their barrels in formation.
Eventually we settled on Lead Styphnate as the explosive. All American commercial ammo has been loaded with this priming since the 1940s, military ammo was phased in as the ordnance types became comfortable with these primers ability to work after decades of storage. This explosive, and the fuels that extend the flame, are all non corrosive now, nor do they attack the brass in the cartridge case. However, some foreign ammunition, especially military surplus, is still corrosive. If there is any question at all, err on the side of caution. Water is cheap. Just run a half-dozen or so sopping wet patches through, a couple of dry patches and then clean normally. Save peeing down the barrel for real emergencies.
In addition to the explosive Lead Styphnate, there is fuel and oxidyzer involved. Then there is a thin piece of foil put in. Then a little three legged anvil is put in and the whole affair is covered in shellac to waterproof it. In my youth these coatings were somewhat iffy. Handling primers with the slightest bit of oil on the fingers would kill them. In the last few decades the primer manufacturers have made great strides in oilproofing them. A couple of years back, in response to an argument on a shooting bulletin board I used to frequent, I conducted an experiment. I took a batch of primed cartridge cases and poured various things into them, enough to soak through the flash holes. I then left those cases for a week, and put them in my revolver and popped them off. I used WD-40, Remington Gun Oil, Three In One Oil and Kroil, a penetrating oil. Every one popped. This is by no means a definitive test, I only used one size and two brands of primers, Federal and Winchester Small Pistol. It is an indicator of just how far the technology has come since I was a boy. Naturally these advances came along after I got priming tools that eliminated the need for ever handling individual primers by hand. Even so, I like those tools, they're faster and more precise.
The difference between rifle and pistol primers is chiefly the amount of priming compound and the hardness of the cup. The rifle primer cups are thicker and stronger than in pistol primers, primarily because of the higher pressures involved. There are very few applications where one can safely use pistol primers in rifle cartridges and vice versa. About the only one that is widely accepted is in a cartridge like the .22 Hornet. Some specialty cartridges, the .454 Casull Magnum for instance, is made for the small rifle primer. I think I remember reading that the .500 S&W is also a small rifle but don't bet the farm on that.
When messing with primers one should bear in mind that a primer is the only part of a smokeless powder cartridge that is explosive and the only thing that is designed to pop by an impact. The packaging of primers is specifically designed to protect from such impacts. Primers should be kept in the original packaging until used. I'm aware of one case where a feller decided that he wanted to keep his primers protected from moisture so he dumped several thousand in a mason jar. He got away with it for quite some time. Eventually, though, it caught up with him and a bunch of them exploded while he was pouring some out of the jar. Didn't kill him but between broken glass and pieces of primers, well, he just wasn't very good looking anymore. Avoid jackass stunts, too. I know of a kid who wanted to hear some bangs so he set some primers on a concrete floor and whacked them with a hammer. They popped all right and the little anvil of one primer went into his cheek, just below the eye. Went right down to the bone, too. An inch higher and he would've been wearing an eyepatch. There used to be black dust that was escaped priming compound found in the tubes or trays of the various priming tools and, if we let it build up, became a danger. I haven't seen that dust lately, probably the same advances in water and oil proofing keeps the priming compound where it belongs. Still, if you see dust building up on your priming tools, clean it off with a damp towel or something.
Changing primers in a load can have an effect on pressure, velocity and accuracy. Usually we see minor pressure and velocity changes and they aren't always predictable. I have a pal who did extensive pressure and velocity testing on the .30-06 cartridge, testing dozens of loads with the same cartridge case, bullet and powder charge, changing only the primer. He saw no changes in pressure that would render a load unsafe unless that load was already at the red line. I keep my loads away from there anyway. If we are shooting a max load and want to try a different primer, back off and work up to max again. I don't have pressure testing gear, I have to work off visual signs and measurements of the fired cases so I do one last step to see if a load is safe. I load a very small batch and shoot it, reload the case and shoot it again. I repeat this until the primer pocket gets loose. If I can't get AT LEAST a half dozen loads out of a case, that load is too hot for long term use. I'd rather have more, like ten.
Well, that's about all I know about primers worth telling and probably far more than most people want to know. Next week we can begin exploring how to put all these parts together.
Update...after posting this I realized that I never explained what the anvil is. It's a little piece of metal shaped like the DANGER! RADIATION sign, that sits at the very top of the primer. The lead styphnate explosive, along with the fuel and oxidyzer is crushed between the cup and the anvil when the firing pin hits. A close look at a Boxer primer under a lottle magnification shows us that the 'feet' of the anvil stick out just a tiny bit past the cup. When we prime a case it gives the anvil a good solid base to resist the blow from the firing pin. That also serves to pre-stress the priming pellet, the mix of explosive, fuel and oxidyzer, increasing the sensitivity.
I also failled to mention the new lead-free primers for use in indoor ranges. These are, at present, only available in certain types of factory ammunition. The people who make them say that they won't be available to ordinary handloaders for the forseeable future as they require loading techniques that aren't available to us. Some indoor ranges do not allow lead bullets because they aren't well enough ventilated to keep the lead exposure to the range personel at a safe level. Since many of these ranges are police training ranges, owned by governments, instead of fixing the ventilation systems, they decided to blame the ammo makers. Typical. Since the lead-free ammunition is quite a bit more expensive than standard lead bullet reloads, it would be cheaper to simply install some decent ventilation systems. I remember the days when police practice ammo was reloaded, the work being done by trustees in the jails. Since petty criminals are rarely magna cum laude types this might remove some of the aura of difficulty and danger surrounding handloading.
Large rifle and pistol primers measure .210 inch across, while small rifle and pistol primers measure .175.
An interesting historical fact is that two different people on opposite sides of the Atlantic Ocean invented the metallic centerfire primer at about the same time. The American,Hiram Berdan, invented a primer that require the anvil (more on what the anvil is and does in a minute) to be part of the cartridge case, eliminating the possibility of one central flash hole.
At the same about time a British Ordnance Officer, Edward Boxer, invented a primer that had an integral anvil. This made primer manufacture a little more complicated but simplified cartridge case manufacture. It also made handloading quite a bit easier,
In an interesting twist, the Berdan Primer, invented in America, is used in Europe and Britain while the Boxer Primer, invented in Britain, is used in the USA. This is primarily because the reloading of cartridges was very rare in Europe while very common in the US. Berdan primed cases are a major pain to try to reload. There are only two ways to decap a Berdan primed case, there is a decapping tool that like an old fashioned can opener, punches a hole in the primer and the handloader prys the cap out by using that hole. This, um, sort of works. Then there's the hydraulic method. Fill the case with water, put a tight-fitting rod in and rap it with a hammer. Water squirts everywhere and, after enough tries, the primer is pushed out. Do not try this outside in Wisconsin in the dead of winter. With it's central flash hole the Boxer primed case is easy to decap, a decapping pin in the sizing die pops it right out. Back in the day, a lot of foreign cartridges were only available in Berdan priming. Those cartridges were also expensive and hard to find. I've reloaded some of those, I hope to never do so again. Thanks to the size of the American market, even European companies like Norma, Sellior and Benoit and Lapua have shifted to Boxer priming.
If it weren't for handloading the Berdan priming system would be superior. The small size of the individual parts of a primer means that the fewer parts, the better. The two, or even three, flash holes in a Berdan primed case can make for more consistent and reliable ignition. It's not worth the hassle to the handloader, though.
The Boxer Primer is built from several different parts. First is the cup, that's the outside of the primer, a stamping of thin, fairly soft metal, usually brass, that contains everything else. Next is a very small amount of explosive. This explosive has changed over the generations. The first used was Mercury Fulminate. This was very effective with Black Powder. When smokeless came along the shooters of the day discovered discovered a major problem, the mercury attacked the brass of the cartridge case. Black powder left so much residue behind that it diluted that mercury so much that it was harmless.
The ammomakers searched for a replacement and found Potassium Chorate. The drawback to the Potassium Chlorate is that it leaves Potassium Chloride, chemically very much like salt, behind. This salt is hygroscopic, meaning it attracts moisture. This causes rust. In the old days this didn't matter, shooters were used to black powder the residue of that is just as prone to cause rust. As the memory of black powder faded shooters stopped cleaning their shootin' irons with soap and water. The solvents and oils used did nothing to wash that salt out of the barrel and shooters wondered why their barrels rusted. Meanwhile, military shooters knew to use water and their bores remained in good shape. American military ammunition continued using these primers up into the 1950s as they had to be concerned with long storage. As a youngster I shot a lot of surplus ammunition with such priming. My WW2 veteran mentors taught me exactly how to prevent rust along with stories of what did when water was short. In my youthful imagination I envisioned some eight million soldiers all peeing down their barrels in formation.
Eventually we settled on Lead Styphnate as the explosive. All American commercial ammo has been loaded with this priming since the 1940s, military ammo was phased in as the ordnance types became comfortable with these primers ability to work after decades of storage. This explosive, and the fuels that extend the flame, are all non corrosive now, nor do they attack the brass in the cartridge case. However, some foreign ammunition, especially military surplus, is still corrosive. If there is any question at all, err on the side of caution. Water is cheap. Just run a half-dozen or so sopping wet patches through, a couple of dry patches and then clean normally. Save peeing down the barrel for real emergencies.
In addition to the explosive Lead Styphnate, there is fuel and oxidyzer involved. Then there is a thin piece of foil put in. Then a little three legged anvil is put in and the whole affair is covered in shellac to waterproof it. In my youth these coatings were somewhat iffy. Handling primers with the slightest bit of oil on the fingers would kill them. In the last few decades the primer manufacturers have made great strides in oilproofing them. A couple of years back, in response to an argument on a shooting bulletin board I used to frequent, I conducted an experiment. I took a batch of primed cartridge cases and poured various things into them, enough to soak through the flash holes. I then left those cases for a week, and put them in my revolver and popped them off. I used WD-40, Remington Gun Oil, Three In One Oil and Kroil, a penetrating oil. Every one popped. This is by no means a definitive test, I only used one size and two brands of primers, Federal and Winchester Small Pistol. It is an indicator of just how far the technology has come since I was a boy. Naturally these advances came along after I got priming tools that eliminated the need for ever handling individual primers by hand. Even so, I like those tools, they're faster and more precise.
The difference between rifle and pistol primers is chiefly the amount of priming compound and the hardness of the cup. The rifle primer cups are thicker and stronger than in pistol primers, primarily because of the higher pressures involved. There are very few applications where one can safely use pistol primers in rifle cartridges and vice versa. About the only one that is widely accepted is in a cartridge like the .22 Hornet. Some specialty cartridges, the .454 Casull Magnum for instance, is made for the small rifle primer. I think I remember reading that the .500 S&W is also a small rifle but don't bet the farm on that.
When messing with primers one should bear in mind that a primer is the only part of a smokeless powder cartridge that is explosive and the only thing that is designed to pop by an impact. The packaging of primers is specifically designed to protect from such impacts. Primers should be kept in the original packaging until used. I'm aware of one case where a feller decided that he wanted to keep his primers protected from moisture so he dumped several thousand in a mason jar. He got away with it for quite some time. Eventually, though, it caught up with him and a bunch of them exploded while he was pouring some out of the jar. Didn't kill him but between broken glass and pieces of primers, well, he just wasn't very good looking anymore. Avoid jackass stunts, too. I know of a kid who wanted to hear some bangs so he set some primers on a concrete floor and whacked them with a hammer. They popped all right and the little anvil of one primer went into his cheek, just below the eye. Went right down to the bone, too. An inch higher and he would've been wearing an eyepatch. There used to be black dust that was escaped priming compound found in the tubes or trays of the various priming tools and, if we let it build up, became a danger. I haven't seen that dust lately, probably the same advances in water and oil proofing keeps the priming compound where it belongs. Still, if you see dust building up on your priming tools, clean it off with a damp towel or something.
Changing primers in a load can have an effect on pressure, velocity and accuracy. Usually we see minor pressure and velocity changes and they aren't always predictable. I have a pal who did extensive pressure and velocity testing on the .30-06 cartridge, testing dozens of loads with the same cartridge case, bullet and powder charge, changing only the primer. He saw no changes in pressure that would render a load unsafe unless that load was already at the red line. I keep my loads away from there anyway. If we are shooting a max load and want to try a different primer, back off and work up to max again. I don't have pressure testing gear, I have to work off visual signs and measurements of the fired cases so I do one last step to see if a load is safe. I load a very small batch and shoot it, reload the case and shoot it again. I repeat this until the primer pocket gets loose. If I can't get AT LEAST a half dozen loads out of a case, that load is too hot for long term use. I'd rather have more, like ten.
Well, that's about all I know about primers worth telling and probably far more than most people want to know. Next week we can begin exploring how to put all these parts together.
Update...after posting this I realized that I never explained what the anvil is. It's a little piece of metal shaped like the DANGER! RADIATION sign, that sits at the very top of the primer. The lead styphnate explosive, along with the fuel and oxidyzer is crushed between the cup and the anvil when the firing pin hits. A close look at a Boxer primer under a lottle magnification shows us that the 'feet' of the anvil stick out just a tiny bit past the cup. When we prime a case it gives the anvil a good solid base to resist the blow from the firing pin. That also serves to pre-stress the priming pellet, the mix of explosive, fuel and oxidyzer, increasing the sensitivity.
I also failled to mention the new lead-free primers for use in indoor ranges. These are, at present, only available in certain types of factory ammunition. The people who make them say that they won't be available to ordinary handloaders for the forseeable future as they require loading techniques that aren't available to us. Some indoor ranges do not allow lead bullets because they aren't well enough ventilated to keep the lead exposure to the range personel at a safe level. Since many of these ranges are police training ranges, owned by governments, instead of fixing the ventilation systems, they decided to blame the ammo makers. Typical. Since the lead-free ammunition is quite a bit more expensive than standard lead bullet reloads, it would be cheaper to simply install some decent ventilation systems. I remember the days when police practice ammo was reloaded, the work being done by trustees in the jails. Since petty criminals are rarely magna cum laude types this might remove some of the aura of difficulty and danger surrounding handloading.
Friday, July 08, 2005
Sometimes I Kill Snakes, A Lesson For Islam
I don't usually kill Rattlesnakes when I see them, unless they're in the yard or some place where kids or my dogs play. I'm too fat for a rattlesnake to eat and unless I'm hunting, I make enough noise moving around in snake country to where they have plenty of time to avoid me. Rattlesnakes aren't all THAT aggressive, they won't bite something too big to eat unless, in their tiny reptilian brains, they feel cornered. I wouldn't ever kill them if not for the fact that kids and dogs can get into an accidental confrontation. I dislike killing anything without reason. The rule on rattlesnakes is that when I'm in their habitat I leave them be, they need to stay out of my habitat. If they don't, too bad for them.
Cottonmouths, on the other hand, will go out of their way to bite, even something too big to eat. They are the reason that the first round under the hammer is a shotshell. When I kill a snake it's not out of hatred, I actually think snakes are kind of cool. We don't have any giant anacondas or humongous boa constrictors so I leave non venomous snakes be, even in the yard. My rule is a simple one with snakes, if they aren't dangerous to me or mine, they go about their snakey business unmolested by me. If they are dangerous, I kill them. Without hatred, without anger and without regret. While I will kill the snakes that endanger me or mine, I'm equally aware of the role they play in nature. Kill them I will, though.
I am hardly unusual, most people living in snake country have more or less the same policy. The days of the indiscriminate killing of any snake seen are pretty well gone. Mature adults judge the danger and act accordingly. People living in Coral snake country learn to tell a venomous coral snake from the harmless, and beneficial, King Snake. There is a little rhyme..."Red touch yella, kill a fella, red touch black, friend of Jack". This rhyme refers to the stripes on Coral Snakes and the harmless other kinds of stripey snakes. If the red stripes touch the black stripe, it's a non venomous snake. Red and yellow, it's venomous. Don't ask me who Jack is.
Here's how this relates to Islamic terrorism. Snakes are easily recognizable. I can tell a venomous snake by sight. Most, like the Rattlesnakes of my home range, have a peculiar head shape. Others, like the Coral snake have a distinctive color scheme and there ain't nothin' but a Cottonmouth that looks like a Cottonmouth. The trouble with Islamic terrorists is that they have no such distinctive appearance. If they did, it would be very easy to root them out. They don't have a distinctive head shape, nor color scheme. This is how they manage to present a danger. Unfortunately they don't just present a danger to us Infidels. There was a time, before we learned to differentiate between venomous snakes and harmless ones, snakes, of any kind, were killed on sight. If there was no easy way to distinguish the harmless from the venomous, they still would be.
My father's generation did not have the precision weaponry of today. In order to stop the German armaments industry they destroyed whole cities. Same with the Japanese. We slaughtered hundreds of thousands of innocent civilians to break the backs of the war machines. It worked. We, knowing that the vast majority of those we killed were not our targets, accepted the useless slaughter in order to destroy those targets.
I'm told that only a small minority of Muslims have any interest at all in the cause of the Islamists. I'm further told that few, indeed, share the goals and the hatred. The problem is, the (allegedly) vast majority of Muslims who neither share the goals or support the methods of the Islamists, do little or nothing to distance themselves from this small minority. They do little or nothing to expel and expose this supposedly small minority. This needs to change, and soon. History is replete with the ashes of the innocent who allowed evil a place to work. Hamburg. Berlin. Shwienfurt. Tokyo. Nagoya. Hiroshima. Nagasaki. That list could go on. Every major city in Germany and Japan lay in ruins. The ashes of the guilty mixed with the innocent.
The young men who unleashed this terrible destruction did not hate, they did not revel in the deaths they caused. Americans and Britons did not dance in the streets nor pass out sweets to children after the firestorms of Hamburg. It was a grim, distasteful and dirty, not to mention dangerous, chore.
Today the clock is ticking. The Islamists are trying hard to find a way to deliver something more powerful than a handful of conventional-explosive bombs. More destructive than wide-body jets. When they do they will unleash a destruction the likes of which haven't been seen since Carthage. We, in the West, will eliminate the Islamists, Islam will be the collateral damage. We won't be able to take the risk of allowing the supposed peaceful majority to survive. I wish the Islamists hiding in America, plotting to kill my children and grandchildren, had the distinctive head shape or peculiar coloration that would allow me to tell them from the majority of peaceful Muslims. They don't. The time is coming when I shall be forced to choose between the safety of my children and the collateral damage of those peaceful Muslims I would have to kill to eliminate the Islamists they allow in their midst.
The Bin Ladens are looking at the wrong examples of history. They look at Somalia instead of Dresden. They look at the USS Cole instead of Nagasaki. They forget what we do when our very lives and way of life is threatened.
The clock is ticking. The choice belongs to that majority of peaceful Muslims. I pray they choose wisely.
Cottonmouths, on the other hand, will go out of their way to bite, even something too big to eat. They are the reason that the first round under the hammer is a shotshell. When I kill a snake it's not out of hatred, I actually think snakes are kind of cool. We don't have any giant anacondas or humongous boa constrictors so I leave non venomous snakes be, even in the yard. My rule is a simple one with snakes, if they aren't dangerous to me or mine, they go about their snakey business unmolested by me. If they are dangerous, I kill them. Without hatred, without anger and without regret. While I will kill the snakes that endanger me or mine, I'm equally aware of the role they play in nature. Kill them I will, though.
I am hardly unusual, most people living in snake country have more or less the same policy. The days of the indiscriminate killing of any snake seen are pretty well gone. Mature adults judge the danger and act accordingly. People living in Coral snake country learn to tell a venomous coral snake from the harmless, and beneficial, King Snake. There is a little rhyme..."Red touch yella, kill a fella, red touch black, friend of Jack". This rhyme refers to the stripes on Coral Snakes and the harmless other kinds of stripey snakes. If the red stripes touch the black stripe, it's a non venomous snake. Red and yellow, it's venomous. Don't ask me who Jack is.
Here's how this relates to Islamic terrorism. Snakes are easily recognizable. I can tell a venomous snake by sight. Most, like the Rattlesnakes of my home range, have a peculiar head shape. Others, like the Coral snake have a distinctive color scheme and there ain't nothin' but a Cottonmouth that looks like a Cottonmouth. The trouble with Islamic terrorists is that they have no such distinctive appearance. If they did, it would be very easy to root them out. They don't have a distinctive head shape, nor color scheme. This is how they manage to present a danger. Unfortunately they don't just present a danger to us Infidels. There was a time, before we learned to differentiate between venomous snakes and harmless ones, snakes, of any kind, were killed on sight. If there was no easy way to distinguish the harmless from the venomous, they still would be.
My father's generation did not have the precision weaponry of today. In order to stop the German armaments industry they destroyed whole cities. Same with the Japanese. We slaughtered hundreds of thousands of innocent civilians to break the backs of the war machines. It worked. We, knowing that the vast majority of those we killed were not our targets, accepted the useless slaughter in order to destroy those targets.
I'm told that only a small minority of Muslims have any interest at all in the cause of the Islamists. I'm further told that few, indeed, share the goals and the hatred. The problem is, the (allegedly) vast majority of Muslims who neither share the goals or support the methods of the Islamists, do little or nothing to distance themselves from this small minority. They do little or nothing to expel and expose this supposedly small minority. This needs to change, and soon. History is replete with the ashes of the innocent who allowed evil a place to work. Hamburg. Berlin. Shwienfurt. Tokyo. Nagoya. Hiroshima. Nagasaki. That list could go on. Every major city in Germany and Japan lay in ruins. The ashes of the guilty mixed with the innocent.
The young men who unleashed this terrible destruction did not hate, they did not revel in the deaths they caused. Americans and Britons did not dance in the streets nor pass out sweets to children after the firestorms of Hamburg. It was a grim, distasteful and dirty, not to mention dangerous, chore.
Today the clock is ticking. The Islamists are trying hard to find a way to deliver something more powerful than a handful of conventional-explosive bombs. More destructive than wide-body jets. When they do they will unleash a destruction the likes of which haven't been seen since Carthage. We, in the West, will eliminate the Islamists, Islam will be the collateral damage. We won't be able to take the risk of allowing the supposed peaceful majority to survive. I wish the Islamists hiding in America, plotting to kill my children and grandchildren, had the distinctive head shape or peculiar coloration that would allow me to tell them from the majority of peaceful Muslims. They don't. The time is coming when I shall be forced to choose between the safety of my children and the collateral damage of those peaceful Muslims I would have to kill to eliminate the Islamists they allow in their midst.
The Bin Ladens are looking at the wrong examples of history. They look at Somalia instead of Dresden. They look at the USS Cole instead of Nagasaki. They forget what we do when our very lives and way of life is threatened.
The clock is ticking. The choice belongs to that majority of peaceful Muslims. I pray they choose wisely.
Thursday, July 07, 2005
Cartridge Case. Our Gas Tank.
Since I have nothing useful to add about the London bombings I shall merely continue with my online exploration of the cartridge. Once we explore the components we'll take a look at how we can make our own ammunition.
The humble cartridge case is the heart of the art and science of handloading. It is the fuel tank, it's an envelope that holds everything together, it's a gasket to keep the pressure from the powder gases from going in undesired directions and it's a jig to keep all the other components in the right alignment to work together. The non-handloader tends to forget that last, the factory worries about alignment so (s)he doesn't have to. I shall discuss alignment in detail when we get into 'how to' part of this series.
Cartridge cases are classified by their priming system, centerfire and rimfire. Rimfire cases are, once fired, scrap metal, they cannot be reloaded. Their rims are folded with a space between the folds. The priming compound is then dabbed in as a thin paste and they were spun in a sort of centrifuge to get the goo into the rim, allowed to dry and then loaded. The factories may well have figured out a more efficient way to do this since I studied up on it as a boy. It doesn't much matter, even if they have I still can't reprime them, nor can I iron out the dent from the firing pin. One of the biggest makers of handloading equipment, Buzz Huntington, got his start making the equipment to turn those fired .22 cases into bullet jackets. When I was a kid varmint hunters still made their own bullets with them. Huntington called it the Rock Chucker Bullet Swage and the company is called RCBS.
It is the centerfire case that interests me, it's the one I can do something with. Centerfire cases are further classified by the method used in controlling headspace. This is a very important word, headspace, I shall lift the definition directly from the glossary of my Speer Manual #13.
Headspace: the distance from that surface of the barrel or chamber that prevents the cartridge from moving further forward into the chamber, to the face of the breech with the action fully closed and locked. This is the most important dimension governing the safety of the shooter. In handloading the combination of cartridge case and firearm must be considered when talking of headspace. To a handloader, few guns need have excessive headspace, since he can adjust the case to fit the chamber, even though the chamber may have excessive headspace when measured by SAAMI standards.
We'll discuss this more, also when we get into the how to part, right now it's enough to know that there are four main ways that we control the headspace, by the rim of the case, by the shoulder of a bottlenecked case, by a belt near the casehead and, in most autoloading pistol cases, by the mouth of the case. We only have a few thousandths of an inch to play with in this, too little and the cartridge doesn't allow the action to close and lock, too much and the firing pin won't reach the primer. Or worse, it reaches the primer allowing the cartridge to fire, yet enough of the brass is unsupported by the steel of the gun to get a KABOOM! The shooter should keep this in mind, the brass of the cartridge case itself is not strong enough to hold the pressure of a high intensity round if not supported by the steel of the firearm.
The rimmed cartridge is the easiest headspace system to visualize, drop the cartridge into the chamber of a revolver and the front of the rim stops it from falling all the way through. Rimmed cartridges are used in revolvers, single shot and lever action rifles and, of course, all rimfires. The rimmed cartridge case would be the only type needed except for the box magazine. The rimmed cartridges don't work particularly well in them. The length of a rimmed cartridge is not particularly important, allowing us to shoot .38 Special cartridges in a .357, for instance, unless it gets so long that it either won't chamber or, worse, will chamber but is jammed so that the caseneck can't expand to release the bullet normally. This causes pressures to skyrocket and had been the cause of more than a few KABOOMS!
The advent of smokeless powder actually brought us the rimless cartridge. The velocities that smokeless made possible made our modern sharp-pointed bullets useful. Sharp pointed bullets and the tubular magazines of the day weren't (and still aren't) a good mix. So most every military in the world went to box magazines, sharp pointed bullets and rimless cartridges, everybody but the Brits. They insisted on sticking with their rimmed .303 and using the difficult to manufacture and oddly shaped magazine in their Lee-Enfields. Headspace on rimless cases is measured from the head of the case to a point on the approximate middle of the shoulder called the 'datum line. A bottlenecked case is the easiest in which we can adjust for a rifle with out of spec headspace in a process called fireforming. The term rimless is actually a misnomer, there is a rim, there has to be to give the extractor something to grab. The rim simply doesn't stick out past the body of the case.
The belted cartridge is simply an attempt to make a rim that will work in the box magazine. We can blame the belted case on Cordite. Cordite, for some reason that if I ever learned I've forgotten, didn't work particularly well in cases with a fairly sharp shoulder angle. Perhaps it was simply a matter of it being long strands. At any rate the belt worked reasonably well in magazines and fairly well to stop the cartridge where it was supposed to. The only cartridges I'm aware of that need that belt are the original Holland and Holland numbers. The trouble is that the wildcatters of the twenties to fifties seized upon those H&H cases because they had more room for powder than the standard cases of the day. Thus the belt became a symbol for power and we are just lately getting away from them. In a modern, sharp-shouldered case the belt does nothing but add expense. Savvy handloaders ignore the belt and adjust their loading dies to headspace on the shoulder.
Rimless straight-walled (mostly) handgun cases headspace on the casemouth. Instead of a gentle angle like a revolver the chamber has a little 'shelf' that stops the case. The person handloading for the .45 ACP and the 9mm Luger should pay special attention to the case length. As the case expands on firing and is squoze down in resizing it will tend to lengthen. If it lengthens too much it will prevent the slide from going fully into battery. In most autoloader this just means a failure to fire. Beware, though, some can fire. When that happens the butt end of the case is unsupported, the high pressure gas blows through the comparatively weak brass and blows the magazine and grips to pieces. Considering that one is gripping those grips at the time, that's not fun. Fortunately(?) it's not common for autoloading pistol brass to last long enough to stretch to the danger point. Between the ejector grabbing it and tearing up the rim and it getting thrown out in the weeds, we don't usually get that many loads out of those cases.
I won't go into detail about how a cartridge case is formed, a description of the process would add more than I've already written. It's quite a process though. Most people don't realize how many operations it takes. Nor do we realize that through a combination of work hardening and annealing the mouth of the cartridge case is considerably softer and more ductile than the head of the case.
The cartridge case is the most expensive part of the cartridge, some uncommon cases can cost over two dollars each. Other cartridges, not all of which are from the 19th Century are no longer made and the only way to get ammunition for the firearms is to make them, starting with the cartridge case. Often they can be made from another case fairly simply, sometimes it's a very laborious process.
The humble cartridge case is the heart of the art and science of handloading. It is the fuel tank, it's an envelope that holds everything together, it's a gasket to keep the pressure from the powder gases from going in undesired directions and it's a jig to keep all the other components in the right alignment to work together. The non-handloader tends to forget that last, the factory worries about alignment so (s)he doesn't have to. I shall discuss alignment in detail when we get into 'how to' part of this series.
Cartridge cases are classified by their priming system, centerfire and rimfire. Rimfire cases are, once fired, scrap metal, they cannot be reloaded. Their rims are folded with a space between the folds. The priming compound is then dabbed in as a thin paste and they were spun in a sort of centrifuge to get the goo into the rim, allowed to dry and then loaded. The factories may well have figured out a more efficient way to do this since I studied up on it as a boy. It doesn't much matter, even if they have I still can't reprime them, nor can I iron out the dent from the firing pin. One of the biggest makers of handloading equipment, Buzz Huntington, got his start making the equipment to turn those fired .22 cases into bullet jackets. When I was a kid varmint hunters still made their own bullets with them. Huntington called it the Rock Chucker Bullet Swage and the company is called RCBS.
It is the centerfire case that interests me, it's the one I can do something with. Centerfire cases are further classified by the method used in controlling headspace. This is a very important word, headspace, I shall lift the definition directly from the glossary of my Speer Manual #13.
Headspace: the distance from that surface of the barrel or chamber that prevents the cartridge from moving further forward into the chamber, to the face of the breech with the action fully closed and locked. This is the most important dimension governing the safety of the shooter. In handloading the combination of cartridge case and firearm must be considered when talking of headspace. To a handloader, few guns need have excessive headspace, since he can adjust the case to fit the chamber, even though the chamber may have excessive headspace when measured by SAAMI standards.
We'll discuss this more, also when we get into the how to part, right now it's enough to know that there are four main ways that we control the headspace, by the rim of the case, by the shoulder of a bottlenecked case, by a belt near the casehead and, in most autoloading pistol cases, by the mouth of the case. We only have a few thousandths of an inch to play with in this, too little and the cartridge doesn't allow the action to close and lock, too much and the firing pin won't reach the primer. Or worse, it reaches the primer allowing the cartridge to fire, yet enough of the brass is unsupported by the steel of the gun to get a KABOOM! The shooter should keep this in mind, the brass of the cartridge case itself is not strong enough to hold the pressure of a high intensity round if not supported by the steel of the firearm.
The rimmed cartridge is the easiest headspace system to visualize, drop the cartridge into the chamber of a revolver and the front of the rim stops it from falling all the way through. Rimmed cartridges are used in revolvers, single shot and lever action rifles and, of course, all rimfires. The rimmed cartridge case would be the only type needed except for the box magazine. The rimmed cartridges don't work particularly well in them. The length of a rimmed cartridge is not particularly important, allowing us to shoot .38 Special cartridges in a .357, for instance, unless it gets so long that it either won't chamber or, worse, will chamber but is jammed so that the caseneck can't expand to release the bullet normally. This causes pressures to skyrocket and had been the cause of more than a few KABOOMS!
The advent of smokeless powder actually brought us the rimless cartridge. The velocities that smokeless made possible made our modern sharp-pointed bullets useful. Sharp pointed bullets and the tubular magazines of the day weren't (and still aren't) a good mix. So most every military in the world went to box magazines, sharp pointed bullets and rimless cartridges, everybody but the Brits. They insisted on sticking with their rimmed .303 and using the difficult to manufacture and oddly shaped magazine in their Lee-Enfields. Headspace on rimless cases is measured from the head of the case to a point on the approximate middle of the shoulder called the 'datum line. A bottlenecked case is the easiest in which we can adjust for a rifle with out of spec headspace in a process called fireforming. The term rimless is actually a misnomer, there is a rim, there has to be to give the extractor something to grab. The rim simply doesn't stick out past the body of the case.
The belted cartridge is simply an attempt to make a rim that will work in the box magazine. We can blame the belted case on Cordite. Cordite, for some reason that if I ever learned I've forgotten, didn't work particularly well in cases with a fairly sharp shoulder angle. Perhaps it was simply a matter of it being long strands. At any rate the belt worked reasonably well in magazines and fairly well to stop the cartridge where it was supposed to. The only cartridges I'm aware of that need that belt are the original Holland and Holland numbers. The trouble is that the wildcatters of the twenties to fifties seized upon those H&H cases because they had more room for powder than the standard cases of the day. Thus the belt became a symbol for power and we are just lately getting away from them. In a modern, sharp-shouldered case the belt does nothing but add expense. Savvy handloaders ignore the belt and adjust their loading dies to headspace on the shoulder.
Rimless straight-walled (mostly) handgun cases headspace on the casemouth. Instead of a gentle angle like a revolver the chamber has a little 'shelf' that stops the case. The person handloading for the .45 ACP and the 9mm Luger should pay special attention to the case length. As the case expands on firing and is squoze down in resizing it will tend to lengthen. If it lengthens too much it will prevent the slide from going fully into battery. In most autoloader this just means a failure to fire. Beware, though, some can fire. When that happens the butt end of the case is unsupported, the high pressure gas blows through the comparatively weak brass and blows the magazine and grips to pieces. Considering that one is gripping those grips at the time, that's not fun. Fortunately(?) it's not common for autoloading pistol brass to last long enough to stretch to the danger point. Between the ejector grabbing it and tearing up the rim and it getting thrown out in the weeds, we don't usually get that many loads out of those cases.
I won't go into detail about how a cartridge case is formed, a description of the process would add more than I've already written. It's quite a process though. Most people don't realize how many operations it takes. Nor do we realize that through a combination of work hardening and annealing the mouth of the cartridge case is considerably softer and more ductile than the head of the case.
The cartridge case is the most expensive part of the cartridge, some uncommon cases can cost over two dollars each. Other cartridges, not all of which are from the 19th Century are no longer made and the only way to get ammunition for the firearms is to make them, starting with the cartridge case. Often they can be made from another case fairly simply, sometimes it's a very laborious process.
Saturday, July 02, 2005
Carnival of the Cordite
Is there anyone in Blogdom that doesn't know that Carnival of the Cordite # 20 is up at Gullyborg's Resistance Is Futile?
Friday, July 01, 2005
Help! Beeswax Wads In Black Powder Cartridges.
My first attempt at loading black powder cartridges in the .45 Colt was a mixed affair. They all went BOOM! The accuracy wasn't too bad but the grooves in the bullets don't hold enough of the SPG lube to keep the black powder fouling soft enough to where the cylinder of my revolver will turn after a few shots. I haven't heard of the winning shooters in the Cowboy Action Matches having to stop and take their shootin' irons apart and clean the face of their cylinders in the middle of a stage. Seems I should be getting at least a full gunfull before the cylinder starts dragging.
I've read that a 'grease cookie' placed between a beeswax over-powder wad and a card wad under the bullet will cure the problem. So, I've ordered a block of beeswax but the trouble is, I know nothing about working with the stuff. Here are my questions...
I just melt it in a double boiler and then pour it into a cake pan to get a sheet, right? How thick? Is there anything I have to do to keep the beeswax from sticking to the pan? Do I need a layer of wax paper or some of that dry silicon spray that people use on candle moulds?
It looks like all I have to do is take a thin sheet of beeswax, small enough to be able to handle, press it over the charged case, using the case like a cookie cutter and then push it the rest of the way down with the same little piece of dowel rod that I push the card wad down, then put the glob of bullet lube in, add the card wad and seat the bullet.
Is there anything I'm missing? I mean besides the good sense to use smokeless powder and avoid the whole mess?
I've read that a 'grease cookie' placed between a beeswax over-powder wad and a card wad under the bullet will cure the problem. So, I've ordered a block of beeswax but the trouble is, I know nothing about working with the stuff. Here are my questions...
I just melt it in a double boiler and then pour it into a cake pan to get a sheet, right? How thick? Is there anything I have to do to keep the beeswax from sticking to the pan? Do I need a layer of wax paper or some of that dry silicon spray that people use on candle moulds?
It looks like all I have to do is take a thin sheet of beeswax, small enough to be able to handle, press it over the charged case, using the case like a cookie cutter and then push it the rest of the way down with the same little piece of dowel rod that I push the card wad down, then put the glob of bullet lube in, add the card wad and seat the bullet.
Is there anything I'm missing? I mean besides the good sense to use smokeless powder and avoid the whole mess?
Thursday, June 30, 2005
Gunpowder, An Overview Of Modern Smokeless Propellants
The shooter and handloader is blessed with the widest choice ever of smokeless propellants, commonly called "gunpowder", a misnomer. Gunpowder is that smelly stuff that muzzleloaders stuff down the barrels of those big ol' smokepoles. Commonly called black powder this stuff is a mixture of saltpeter, charcoal and sulfur and is beyond the scope of this particular piece, except to note that for hundreds of years it was all we had.
Black powder has many limitations, it's not particularly efficient in that it doesn't impart a whole lot of power to a bullet, it's messy to work with, it's somewhat dangerous and it leaves a whole bunch of residue behind. The billowing clouds of white smoke were a real drawback in military use. My great grandfathers would be bemused by the resurgence in popularity of black powder.
Smokeless propellants came about, like many of today's conveniences, through military research. The first breakthrough was the discovery that ordinary cellulose in cotton or wood could be soaked in nitric acid to form guncotton in 1845. Guncotton is useless as a propellant as it is impossible to control the burning rate.
Oddly it was a French chemist, a man named Vielle, who made modern smokeless powder possible. He discovered that by soaking guncotton in alcohol and ether one could form it in sheets. Cutting up those sheets into small granules gave us the first smokeless powder. The race was on.
The first cartridge using smokeless was, I believe, a French military cartridge, the 8 mm. Lebel.
Across the Channel the Brits learned that by taking this soft, doughy mixture of wet guncotton and forcing it through a sieve-like apparatus they could make it into a bunch of spaghetti-like strands called "Cordite". It was some decades before they learned to cut up those strands. Initially the Brit ammunition manufacturers simply bundled up a bunch of these cords, shoved them into a cartridge case, then formed the neck of the charged case and inserted the bullet. This wasn't the safest operation in the world. I'm told that the early Brit handloaders were a sight to behold, trying to stick those long cords, one or two at a time, down the neck of a cartridge. All in all, people were extremely relieved when the Brits figured out the concept of cutting those cords up into little pieces.
A factoid about Cordite that some may find interesting is that a large amount of ammonia was used in it's manufacture, along with other chemicals, that gave it a strong, peculiar and unpleasant smell when the cartridges were fired. This gave rise to the term "the stench of Cordite", a term that is still used today by the ignorant. It's been a VERY long time since Cordite was used, the smell of today's propellants is nothing like that. When I was a boy I fired some surplus .303 Brit ammo loaded with Cordite, I know the difference. That ammo was old then, today it would be valuable as a collector's item.
Modern smokeless powder is of two basic types. Single-based powders are made of nitrocellulose. Double-based powders are made of nitrocellulose and nitroglycerine. Each of these types also contain smaller amounts of other chemicals and each is coated in graphite during the manufacturing process. The graphite makes it much easier and safer to work with as it cuts down on static electricity. It's also why smokeless powder is dark gray to black in color. Before the graphite is added the powders are a pale, greenish yellow. A Company in Finland actually makes a powder with yet another ingredient, besides nitrocellulose and nitroglycerine, making it a triple-based powder. The company is Vhita Vouri and the name of the third ingredient escapes me at the moment and I can't seem to get on their website. It will come to me, probably in the middle of some night next week. I'll wake up, shout the name, scare Hell out of the dog, he'll start barking, waking Linda Lou and I'll be in trouble again. Anyhow there are only three of these triple-based powders and I'll pretty much ignore them except to note that they give a velocity boost of some 50-150 feet per second over conventional propellants, at equal pressures.
Besides being classified as to whether they're single, double or triple based, powders are further classified by their kernel structure. By the way, do not refer to each individual speck of powder as a grain. When shooters and handloaders use the word grain, we're referring to a unit of weight. A grain is one seven thousandths of a pound. There are 437.5 grains in an aviorduppois ounce and for those who think in metric, 15.43 grains per gram. Those little bitty pieces of powder can also be called granules.
Back to the classification, powders can be like little bitty sticks, they can be little bitty spheres or flakes and there are some European powders that are formed in big, thin sheets and then die-cut into squares or diamond shapes. The Alcan Powders for shotgun and handgun cartridges were sheet powders, they've been gone for years but they were good stuff. So we call it stick powder, ball powder or flake powder. We Americans don't call sheet powder anything because we never see it.
Stick type powder is quite interesting as it's made like a hollow tube. Each kernel has one or more perforations through it. This is how the burning rate is controlled, by the size of the kernel and the perforation. The spherical or ball powder has it's burning rate controlled by coating each kernel with a chemical that retards burning. Flake-type powders control their burning rate through the chemical composition and granule size. I got to see cannon powder when I wore Uncle's suit, each kernel was big enough to see the perforations.
Smokeless powder is not an explosive, at least in the quantities that even avid shooters keep around not even a particularly dangerous flammable. It doesn't evaporate into a flammable vapor and takes a pretty good spark to light. Unconfined it doesn't even burn very fast. The late General Julian Hatcher, one of the giants of early to mid 20th Century cartridge development, tried to make canisters of smokeless powder explode by shooting into them. It took shooting into a two hundred pound keg before he got anything resembling an explosion, the one and eight pound canisters won't.
The last way we classify powder is by it's burning rate. The way it works is that the powders that are right for loading handgun cartridges are not good for loading full-charge rifle cartridges. There are more than 150 different kinds of powder more or less readily available to the handloader today, each with it's range of uses.
Each one of these powders will not burn efficiently below a given pressure and each becomes quite dangerous when it exceeds a higher given pressure. Generally speaking, the slower the powder, the higher the pressure has to be before it burns efficiently. Another generality...Single based powders USUALLY have a wider range of pressures where they work well than double based powders and they are somewhat more predictable as they approach to upper margin. The short answer as to why is that kernel size stays the same and that's what control's the burning rate in single based powders. In the confined area of a cartridge as the pressure builds, so does the heat, the deterrent coatings that control the burning rate of the double-based ball powders works less well the higher the pressure. That's a very simplified statement as that's the way these coatings are designed to work. Otherwise cartridges would fizzle.
There is no "best" powder. There are usually one or two powders that work best in a particular cartridge in a specific range of bullet weights. That's assuming "best" means highest velocity at safe pressures. We aren't always looking for the highest velocity. The velocity minded handloader can find the powder that delivers for her, or his, cartridge by checking several loading manuals. One or two powders will almost always stand out. Given a choice I always try to go with the powder that gives a mildly compressed load. Why? A compressed load means there isn't enough room in the case to put enough powder in to cause a KABOOM. I like that. I like it a lot.
These days I don't fool with trying to get every last foot-second much. I don't have the wheels for long-ranged hunting, nor, with this Parkinson's, would it be fair to the game to try potting it 'way past Fort Mudge'. So, what little hunting I do is in country where the terrain and cover is such that fifty or a hundred yards is a long poke. At those ranges I don't want high velocity. All high velocity does at close range is waste meat and add noise and recoil. By picking the right powder and bullet I can turn a .30-06, or even one of the .300 Mags, into a .30-30 or .300 Savage. In the words of the late, and sorely missed, Elmer Keith "you can eat right up to the bullet hole".
Handloaders who would like to introduce new shooters to centerfire rifle shooting should be aware of Hodgdon Powder Company's H4895 and the Sixty Percent Rule. Any cartridge for which there is data for H4895 can be loaded at 60% of the maximum load for a load that has far less recoil and muzzle blast than full charge ammo. Then gradually increase the load. These are also wonderful loads for a kid just learning to hunt. They're no kind of squib load. The Sixty Percent Rule will, when used in my .30-06, push Hornaday's excellent 130 grain Single Shot Pistol bullet out at over 2500 fps. Hairy-chested he-men drop deer and even elk with those ballistics and their Thompson Contenders, it'd be just the load for a teenaged daughter.
I talked about the wide array of powders available. I believe the choices are about to contract somewhat. Over the last couple of months there have been some buyouts and mergers. Accurate Powders have been bought by the Western Powder Company, the folks who distribute the Ramshot Powders. And the Hodgdon Powder Company bought IMR. Since many of IMR and Hodgdon's powders are so close together that starting load data can be safely swapped I can see the elimination of near-duplicates. We don't need IMR4895 and H4895, nor H4350 and IMR4350. Hodgdon's Varget and IMR's 4064 are so close together that I've switched according to what was on sale and not had to adjust my scope sight when going from one batch of cartridges to the other.
Will the elimination of the duplication of effort lead to lower prices? I can hope. I'm not holding my breath, though.
Powder is expensive and, depending on the locality, there are limits to how much a private citizen can have on hand without building special storage facilities. The most common amount allowed is twenty pounds. That seems like a lot, it isn't really. A shooter with an autoloading pistol and a magnum revolver, plus just one .30-30 and one high-intensity rifle will go over that limit with a fresh eight pound jug of just one powder per cartridge and what handloader is satisfied with just one powder per cartridge? A quick count in my powder "magazine" shows some twenty-one different smokeless powders, some with more than one jug. Add the only real explosive powders, the canister of FFG Black and that jug of Pyrodex that isn't quite smokeless and isn't quite black. Of course I tend to enjoy experimentation. That's one of the nice things about living in the country. I asked my county Fire Marshall about the specs when I built my magazine. He told me not to put a fireplace in it. I love living in the country. My homeowner's insurance agent was somewhat more picky. Two layers of one inch plywood, covered by twenty gauge steel was the request and please make it lockable. It ain't very pretty, it's just a big box with shelves in it. And a padlock. My insurance agent is happy. If I were doing it again I'd just use a junk refrigerator and put a hasp on it. The insulation on even an old fridge is such that either the fire gets put out or the house would burn down before the powder caught.
When thinking powder safety remember, the fire won't start in the powder unless you do something like looking at the level in the jug by holding a match in there. The whole idea is to try to keep it from adding to a fire that started elsewhere. A thick box, an old refrigerator, even those fire-resistant filing cabinets, any of those will either keep the powder from adding to the fire or the powder won't matter because the house is history anyway.
The most important parts of powder safety have nothing to do with fire. Never mix two or more different kinds of powder. Never have more than one jug of powder on the loading bench at one time. At the beginning of a loading session write the name of the powder you're using down. In big letters. Then look twice to make sure you're putting right powder in the measure and putting the leftover powder back in the right jug. Inadvertently putting pistol or shotgun powder in the measure that's set for your 7mm Remington Magnum is a guaranteed KABOOM.
Smokeless powder when mixed with a little common sense and a willingness to follow the recipe is safe to have around. Far safer than that can of lawn mower gas in the garage. So, for safety's sake, handload, don't mow.
Black powder has many limitations, it's not particularly efficient in that it doesn't impart a whole lot of power to a bullet, it's messy to work with, it's somewhat dangerous and it leaves a whole bunch of residue behind. The billowing clouds of white smoke were a real drawback in military use. My great grandfathers would be bemused by the resurgence in popularity of black powder.
Smokeless propellants came about, like many of today's conveniences, through military research. The first breakthrough was the discovery that ordinary cellulose in cotton or wood could be soaked in nitric acid to form guncotton in 1845. Guncotton is useless as a propellant as it is impossible to control the burning rate.
Oddly it was a French chemist, a man named Vielle, who made modern smokeless powder possible. He discovered that by soaking guncotton in alcohol and ether one could form it in sheets. Cutting up those sheets into small granules gave us the first smokeless powder. The race was on.
The first cartridge using smokeless was, I believe, a French military cartridge, the 8 mm. Lebel.
Across the Channel the Brits learned that by taking this soft, doughy mixture of wet guncotton and forcing it through a sieve-like apparatus they could make it into a bunch of spaghetti-like strands called "Cordite". It was some decades before they learned to cut up those strands. Initially the Brit ammunition manufacturers simply bundled up a bunch of these cords, shoved them into a cartridge case, then formed the neck of the charged case and inserted the bullet. This wasn't the safest operation in the world. I'm told that the early Brit handloaders were a sight to behold, trying to stick those long cords, one or two at a time, down the neck of a cartridge. All in all, people were extremely relieved when the Brits figured out the concept of cutting those cords up into little pieces.
A factoid about Cordite that some may find interesting is that a large amount of ammonia was used in it's manufacture, along with other chemicals, that gave it a strong, peculiar and unpleasant smell when the cartridges were fired. This gave rise to the term "the stench of Cordite", a term that is still used today by the ignorant. It's been a VERY long time since Cordite was used, the smell of today's propellants is nothing like that. When I was a boy I fired some surplus .303 Brit ammo loaded with Cordite, I know the difference. That ammo was old then, today it would be valuable as a collector's item.
Modern smokeless powder is of two basic types. Single-based powders are made of nitrocellulose. Double-based powders are made of nitrocellulose and nitroglycerine. Each of these types also contain smaller amounts of other chemicals and each is coated in graphite during the manufacturing process. The graphite makes it much easier and safer to work with as it cuts down on static electricity. It's also why smokeless powder is dark gray to black in color. Before the graphite is added the powders are a pale, greenish yellow. A Company in Finland actually makes a powder with yet another ingredient, besides nitrocellulose and nitroglycerine, making it a triple-based powder. The company is Vhita Vouri and the name of the third ingredient escapes me at the moment and I can't seem to get on their website. It will come to me, probably in the middle of some night next week. I'll wake up, shout the name, scare Hell out of the dog, he'll start barking, waking Linda Lou and I'll be in trouble again. Anyhow there are only three of these triple-based powders and I'll pretty much ignore them except to note that they give a velocity boost of some 50-150 feet per second over conventional propellants, at equal pressures.
Besides being classified as to whether they're single, double or triple based, powders are further classified by their kernel structure. By the way, do not refer to each individual speck of powder as a grain. When shooters and handloaders use the word grain, we're referring to a unit of weight. A grain is one seven thousandths of a pound. There are 437.5 grains in an aviorduppois ounce and for those who think in metric, 15.43 grains per gram. Those little bitty pieces of powder can also be called granules.
Back to the classification, powders can be like little bitty sticks, they can be little bitty spheres or flakes and there are some European powders that are formed in big, thin sheets and then die-cut into squares or diamond shapes. The Alcan Powders for shotgun and handgun cartridges were sheet powders, they've been gone for years but they were good stuff. So we call it stick powder, ball powder or flake powder. We Americans don't call sheet powder anything because we never see it.
Stick type powder is quite interesting as it's made like a hollow tube. Each kernel has one or more perforations through it. This is how the burning rate is controlled, by the size of the kernel and the perforation. The spherical or ball powder has it's burning rate controlled by coating each kernel with a chemical that retards burning. Flake-type powders control their burning rate through the chemical composition and granule size. I got to see cannon powder when I wore Uncle's suit, each kernel was big enough to see the perforations.
Smokeless powder is not an explosive, at least in the quantities that even avid shooters keep around not even a particularly dangerous flammable. It doesn't evaporate into a flammable vapor and takes a pretty good spark to light. Unconfined it doesn't even burn very fast. The late General Julian Hatcher, one of the giants of early to mid 20th Century cartridge development, tried to make canisters of smokeless powder explode by shooting into them. It took shooting into a two hundred pound keg before he got anything resembling an explosion, the one and eight pound canisters won't.
The last way we classify powder is by it's burning rate. The way it works is that the powders that are right for loading handgun cartridges are not good for loading full-charge rifle cartridges. There are more than 150 different kinds of powder more or less readily available to the handloader today, each with it's range of uses.
Each one of these powders will not burn efficiently below a given pressure and each becomes quite dangerous when it exceeds a higher given pressure. Generally speaking, the slower the powder, the higher the pressure has to be before it burns efficiently. Another generality...Single based powders USUALLY have a wider range of pressures where they work well than double based powders and they are somewhat more predictable as they approach to upper margin. The short answer as to why is that kernel size stays the same and that's what control's the burning rate in single based powders. In the confined area of a cartridge as the pressure builds, so does the heat, the deterrent coatings that control the burning rate of the double-based ball powders works less well the higher the pressure. That's a very simplified statement as that's the way these coatings are designed to work. Otherwise cartridges would fizzle.
There is no "best" powder. There are usually one or two powders that work best in a particular cartridge in a specific range of bullet weights. That's assuming "best" means highest velocity at safe pressures. We aren't always looking for the highest velocity. The velocity minded handloader can find the powder that delivers for her, or his, cartridge by checking several loading manuals. One or two powders will almost always stand out. Given a choice I always try to go with the powder that gives a mildly compressed load. Why? A compressed load means there isn't enough room in the case to put enough powder in to cause a KABOOM. I like that. I like it a lot.
These days I don't fool with trying to get every last foot-second much. I don't have the wheels for long-ranged hunting, nor, with this Parkinson's, would it be fair to the game to try potting it 'way past Fort Mudge'. So, what little hunting I do is in country where the terrain and cover is such that fifty or a hundred yards is a long poke. At those ranges I don't want high velocity. All high velocity does at close range is waste meat and add noise and recoil. By picking the right powder and bullet I can turn a .30-06, or even one of the .300 Mags, into a .30-30 or .300 Savage. In the words of the late, and sorely missed, Elmer Keith "you can eat right up to the bullet hole".
Handloaders who would like to introduce new shooters to centerfire rifle shooting should be aware of Hodgdon Powder Company's H4895 and the Sixty Percent Rule. Any cartridge for which there is data for H4895 can be loaded at 60% of the maximum load for a load that has far less recoil and muzzle blast than full charge ammo. Then gradually increase the load. These are also wonderful loads for a kid just learning to hunt. They're no kind of squib load. The Sixty Percent Rule will, when used in my .30-06, push Hornaday's excellent 130 grain Single Shot Pistol bullet out at over 2500 fps. Hairy-chested he-men drop deer and even elk with those ballistics and their Thompson Contenders, it'd be just the load for a teenaged daughter.
I talked about the wide array of powders available. I believe the choices are about to contract somewhat. Over the last couple of months there have been some buyouts and mergers. Accurate Powders have been bought by the Western Powder Company, the folks who distribute the Ramshot Powders. And the Hodgdon Powder Company bought IMR. Since many of IMR and Hodgdon's powders are so close together that starting load data can be safely swapped I can see the elimination of near-duplicates. We don't need IMR4895 and H4895, nor H4350 and IMR4350. Hodgdon's Varget and IMR's 4064 are so close together that I've switched according to what was on sale and not had to adjust my scope sight when going from one batch of cartridges to the other.
Will the elimination of the duplication of effort lead to lower prices? I can hope. I'm not holding my breath, though.
Powder is expensive and, depending on the locality, there are limits to how much a private citizen can have on hand without building special storage facilities. The most common amount allowed is twenty pounds. That seems like a lot, it isn't really. A shooter with an autoloading pistol and a magnum revolver, plus just one .30-30 and one high-intensity rifle will go over that limit with a fresh eight pound jug of just one powder per cartridge and what handloader is satisfied with just one powder per cartridge? A quick count in my powder "magazine" shows some twenty-one different smokeless powders, some with more than one jug. Add the only real explosive powders, the canister of FFG Black and that jug of Pyrodex that isn't quite smokeless and isn't quite black. Of course I tend to enjoy experimentation. That's one of the nice things about living in the country. I asked my county Fire Marshall about the specs when I built my magazine. He told me not to put a fireplace in it. I love living in the country. My homeowner's insurance agent was somewhat more picky. Two layers of one inch plywood, covered by twenty gauge steel was the request and please make it lockable. It ain't very pretty, it's just a big box with shelves in it. And a padlock. My insurance agent is happy. If I were doing it again I'd just use a junk refrigerator and put a hasp on it. The insulation on even an old fridge is such that either the fire gets put out or the house would burn down before the powder caught.
When thinking powder safety remember, the fire won't start in the powder unless you do something like looking at the level in the jug by holding a match in there. The whole idea is to try to keep it from adding to a fire that started elsewhere. A thick box, an old refrigerator, even those fire-resistant filing cabinets, any of those will either keep the powder from adding to the fire or the powder won't matter because the house is history anyway.
The most important parts of powder safety have nothing to do with fire. Never mix two or more different kinds of powder. Never have more than one jug of powder on the loading bench at one time. At the beginning of a loading session write the name of the powder you're using down. In big letters. Then look twice to make sure you're putting right powder in the measure and putting the leftover powder back in the right jug. Inadvertently putting pistol or shotgun powder in the measure that's set for your 7mm Remington Magnum is a guaranteed KABOOM.
Smokeless powder when mixed with a little common sense and a willingness to follow the recipe is safe to have around. Far safer than that can of lawn mower gas in the garage. So, for safety's sake, handload, don't mow.
Monday, June 27, 2005
I Got It Wrong, Bigtime.
In my post about Captain Chuck Ziegenfuss being wounded I managed to get almost every detail wrong. Worse, I have managed to convey an impression to his friends and family of stupidity on his part. That impression is, most assuredly, wrong. Any stupidity involved rests right behind this keyboard.
Captain Z did not try to dispose of that IED by picking it up and dropping it in the nearby canal. Instead, it seems that it blew up while they were looking for it and the explosion knocked him into that canal. At least I seem to have gotten the part about the raw courage of his XO jumping in after him while weighed down with all that stuff.
I make no excuse. Working through very sketchy information I filtered that info through the faulty prism of a war long ago and far away. That information, filtered through that prism, formed a picture in my mind's eye of what happened that was totally wrong. Worse, I based my post on that wrong picture. I should have known better. Indeed I do know better, most of the profanity I use in my daily life comes directly from reading and hearing descriptions of events filtered through such faulty prisms.
One thing I want to stress, though, is that if the situation had demanded trying to carry a live bomb to a place where it's explosion would have been relatively harmless, doing so would not have been stupid. Incredibly dangerous, yes, stupid, no. I remember such situations. One such was a satchel charge, with the fuse going, that landed inside a TOC bunker during a long and particularly hairy night some thirty-eight years ago. A young radioman was badly wounded getting it out of the bunker, saving everyone inside.
The bottom line? I screwed the pooch. I could go on with why but it would really only be lame excuses. The last point I want to make is that no semi sentinant being, even me, can read Cap'n Z's blog and see any trace of stupidity. Instead we see a bright young family man who follows the profession of arms and does so in the highest traditions of that profession.
I hope everyone involved will accept my profound apologies.
Captain Z did not try to dispose of that IED by picking it up and dropping it in the nearby canal. Instead, it seems that it blew up while they were looking for it and the explosion knocked him into that canal. At least I seem to have gotten the part about the raw courage of his XO jumping in after him while weighed down with all that stuff.
I make no excuse. Working through very sketchy information I filtered that info through the faulty prism of a war long ago and far away. That information, filtered through that prism, formed a picture in my mind's eye of what happened that was totally wrong. Worse, I based my post on that wrong picture. I should have known better. Indeed I do know better, most of the profanity I use in my daily life comes directly from reading and hearing descriptions of events filtered through such faulty prisms.
One thing I want to stress, though, is that if the situation had demanded trying to carry a live bomb to a place where it's explosion would have been relatively harmless, doing so would not have been stupid. Incredibly dangerous, yes, stupid, no. I remember such situations. One such was a satchel charge, with the fuse going, that landed inside a TOC bunker during a long and particularly hairy night some thirty-eight years ago. A young radioman was badly wounded getting it out of the bunker, saving everyone inside.
The bottom line? I screwed the pooch. I could go on with why but it would really only be lame excuses. The last point I want to make is that no semi sentinant being, even me, can read Cap'n Z's blog and see any trace of stupidity. Instead we see a bright young family man who follows the profession of arms and does so in the highest traditions of that profession.
I hope everyone involved will accept my profound apologies.
Sunday, June 26, 2005
The Flag Burning Amendment, A Simple Alternative.
Everybody and their Mother In Law are getting all exersised over the flag burning amendment that passed the House recently. Where I live there doesn't seem to be a big problem, as a matter of fact there seems to be a pretty big problem with flags that aren't being burned that should be. I mean, have you SEEN some of the tattered, dirty and faded remnants on some of these poles?
Still, civil libertarians are up in arms on one side, self-described patriot politicos on the other side and then there are a whole bunch of intellectuals trying to explain to us pore dumb rednecks (actually, it's not my neck that's all that red, it's the reflection off the backs of my sunburnt ears) why it's a good, or bad, idea.
Me, I'm having trouble figuring out why it's okay to burn the flag but city folks can go to jail if'n they burn a pile of leaves in the fall but then I don't really understand city folks anyhow. Somehow the Supreme Court decided that burning the flag is a protected form of free speech. Okay, fine. Then why isn't puttin' a good ol' country butt kickin' on one of these yahoos also a protected form of free speech? Or settin' fire to some of these chuckleheaded judges, for that matter. I can see that the flag pisses some folks off, why I'm not exactly sure. So, we've established the precedent, fire equals speech. How 'bout the Democratic Underground crowd? They piss me off. Under that precedent it seems that I should be allowed to whup up a batch of homemade napalm (I have the recipe) and fire those bad boys up.
So, we've established the precedent that burnin' stuff that we don't approve of equals free speech while it's not free speech to talk about a politician some sixty or ninety days before an election. It doesn't make a lot of sense to me but if that's what they want, hand me the matches. I didn't make the rules but I guess I can live with them. Air quality is really gonna suck for awhile, though. On the plus side, once everyone is done burnin' all the things that piss them off it oughta be a lot less crowded.
Still, civil libertarians are up in arms on one side, self-described patriot politicos on the other side and then there are a whole bunch of intellectuals trying to explain to us pore dumb rednecks (actually, it's not my neck that's all that red, it's the reflection off the backs of my sunburnt ears) why it's a good, or bad, idea.
Me, I'm having trouble figuring out why it's okay to burn the flag but city folks can go to jail if'n they burn a pile of leaves in the fall but then I don't really understand city folks anyhow. Somehow the Supreme Court decided that burning the flag is a protected form of free speech. Okay, fine. Then why isn't puttin' a good ol' country butt kickin' on one of these yahoos also a protected form of free speech? Or settin' fire to some of these chuckleheaded judges, for that matter. I can see that the flag pisses some folks off, why I'm not exactly sure. So, we've established the precedent, fire equals speech. How 'bout the Democratic Underground crowd? They piss me off. Under that precedent it seems that I should be allowed to whup up a batch of homemade napalm (I have the recipe) and fire those bad boys up.
So, we've established the precedent that burnin' stuff that we don't approve of equals free speech while it's not free speech to talk about a politician some sixty or ninety days before an election. It doesn't make a lot of sense to me but if that's what they want, hand me the matches. I didn't make the rules but I guess I can live with them. Air quality is really gonna suck for awhile, though. On the plus side, once everyone is done burnin' all the things that piss them off it oughta be a lot less crowded.
Friday, June 24, 2005
Hero. No, Two heroes and counting.
UPDATE June 27, 2005. I've been told that I managed to get nearly every single detail of of how Captain Ziegenfuss was wounded wrong. The only reason I don't just delete it is that that once something is out there it's out there forever. Please see my correction and apology posted today.
Just about anyone who reads blogs, especially Milblogs has heard that Captain Chuck Ziegenfuss has been wounded in Iraq. Cap'n Z is the proprietor of the Milblog "From My Position, On The Way".
Mrs. Greyhawk, of Mudville Gazette fame visited him in the hospital just as they put him on the gurney to begin the trip to Walter Reed Army Hospital in DC. If my links don't work, as seems to be normal around here, just click the Mudville Gazette link on the sidebar.
What is striking is not that Cap'n Z was almost blowed up by an IED, bomb to us folks who don't savvy milspeak, that is something depressingly common. What is striking is just how he was almost blown up. One doesn't have to be a hero to get blown up, just near the explosion. Someone as timid as myself could be blown up just as easily as any hero. The only thing required is that one be near the explosion. Explosions are well known for their touchiness. They like their privacy and do Bad Things to people who invade it.
Here is what happened, as best I can put it together in my head...
Cap'n Z was commanding a routine patrol when an Iraqi civilian came up and told them about an IED (bomb) somewhere near. The patrol beat feet, actually drove, probably, the reports don't make that clear but Cap'n Z is a tanker and those guys aren't famous for walking, to the bomb's location. Me? I would have picked another destination, maybe Cleveland.
When they got there, instead of staying behind something real solid and shouting "run away, there's a BOMB!!" at the top of his lungs while waiting for the EOD (bomb disposal) squad to show up with their special equipment and training, Cap'n Z decided he had to do something. Since the Army pretty much quit giving company commands to peabrains in the big reorganization after Viet Nam I can only assume there was good reason why he couldn't do the safe thing.
There is an age-old maxim in leadership, never order a PFC to do something you aren't willing to do yourself. Giving new life to this maxim Cap'n Z picked up this IED (BOMB!), carried it to the nearby canal and dropped it in. I'm sure that his working theory was that the water would absorb the shrapnel and most of the blast. Aside from the Wicked Witch of the West and perhaps Hillary, few people are seriously damaged by a splash of water, even a big splash of canal water.
Unfortunately Cap'n Z miscalculated the weight of the IED and the equipment he was carrying and wearing and found himself in that canal, with the IED. The IED then exploded. Pulled down by the weight of his gear and knocked unconscious by the blast, Cap'n Z was dying when Captain Jason Spencer, his XO, jumped into that canal after him. Spencer also found that because of the way the weight of the gear he wore and carried he was head-down in the water. Somehow he got right-side up, and got to his CO and got him where other members of that patrol could pull him out, administer first aid and call for medevac.
By now Cap'n Z is probably at Walter Reed where the Docs will work hard to save the badly injured thumb on his right hand. He lost the pinky finger on his left hand, both arms are in casts and he's got too many dings and scrapes to list. Thanks, though, to the courage of Captain Spencer, who jumped into that canal knowing that the weight of that gear would carry him to the bottom, he's going to live to hold his wife, careen, his son Creighton, age five, and his daughter Adelle, age two.
There was once a day when men would sing songs about such men. Schoolchildren would memorize poems about them and boys would pray to grow up with such courage. The outward expressions are gone, today and it's a shame. Yet, still, America can produce men who will pick up a live IED (BOMB!) and carry it to where it can't hurt anyone.
I can only strive to to be worthy to live in a land that can produce such men. I fear I fall short.
Just about anyone who reads blogs, especially Milblogs has heard that Captain Chuck Ziegenfuss has been wounded in Iraq. Cap'n Z is the proprietor of the Milblog "From My Position, On The Way".
Mrs. Greyhawk, of Mudville Gazette fame visited him in the hospital just as they put him on the gurney to begin the trip to Walter Reed Army Hospital in DC. If my links don't work, as seems to be normal around here, just click the Mudville Gazette link on the sidebar.
What is striking is not that Cap'n Z was almost blowed up by an IED, bomb to us folks who don't savvy milspeak, that is something depressingly common. What is striking is just how he was almost blown up. One doesn't have to be a hero to get blown up, just near the explosion. Someone as timid as myself could be blown up just as easily as any hero. The only thing required is that one be near the explosion. Explosions are well known for their touchiness. They like their privacy and do Bad Things to people who invade it.
Here is what happened, as best I can put it together in my head...
Cap'n Z was commanding a routine patrol when an Iraqi civilian came up and told them about an IED (bomb) somewhere near. The patrol beat feet, actually drove, probably, the reports don't make that clear but Cap'n Z is a tanker and those guys aren't famous for walking, to the bomb's location. Me? I would have picked another destination, maybe Cleveland.
When they got there, instead of staying behind something real solid and shouting "run away, there's a BOMB!!" at the top of his lungs while waiting for the EOD (bomb disposal) squad to show up with their special equipment and training, Cap'n Z decided he had to do something. Since the Army pretty much quit giving company commands to peabrains in the big reorganization after Viet Nam I can only assume there was good reason why he couldn't do the safe thing.
There is an age-old maxim in leadership, never order a PFC to do something you aren't willing to do yourself. Giving new life to this maxim Cap'n Z picked up this IED (BOMB!), carried it to the nearby canal and dropped it in. I'm sure that his working theory was that the water would absorb the shrapnel and most of the blast. Aside from the Wicked Witch of the West and perhaps Hillary, few people are seriously damaged by a splash of water, even a big splash of canal water.
Unfortunately Cap'n Z miscalculated the weight of the IED and the equipment he was carrying and wearing and found himself in that canal, with the IED. The IED then exploded. Pulled down by the weight of his gear and knocked unconscious by the blast, Cap'n Z was dying when Captain Jason Spencer, his XO, jumped into that canal after him. Spencer also found that because of the way the weight of the gear he wore and carried he was head-down in the water. Somehow he got right-side up, and got to his CO and got him where other members of that patrol could pull him out, administer first aid and call for medevac.
By now Cap'n Z is probably at Walter Reed where the Docs will work hard to save the badly injured thumb on his right hand. He lost the pinky finger on his left hand, both arms are in casts and he's got too many dings and scrapes to list. Thanks, though, to the courage of Captain Spencer, who jumped into that canal knowing that the weight of that gear would carry him to the bottom, he's going to live to hold his wife, careen, his son Creighton, age five, and his daughter Adelle, age two.
There was once a day when men would sing songs about such men. Schoolchildren would memorize poems about them and boys would pray to grow up with such courage. The outward expressions are gone, today and it's a shame. Yet, still, America can produce men who will pick up a live IED (BOMB!) and carry it to where it can't hurt anyone.
I can only strive to to be worthy to live in a land that can produce such men. I fear I fall short.
Thursday, June 23, 2005
Cast Bullets, A Primer.
Economy minded shooters have a love-hate relationship with cast bullets. We love the economy, many of us hate the cleanup. I can sympathize, cleaning a badly leaded barrel is one of the biggest pains in the butt since the invention of the hemorrhoid. Many shooters, even handloaders, avoid the lowly lead alloy bullet for this very reason. It doesn't have to be that way.
There is a lot of good information about shooting the lead alloy bullet that has almost passed from general knowledge as our grandparents passed from the scene. The first bit of information that has been lost is that cast bullets don't have to lead a barrel, and won't if they're the right size, hardness and properly lubricated. This, of course, assumes that the barrel in question isn't full of rust, pits and tool marks. The first step in our quest to eliminate barrel leading is to remove all traces of jacket fouling from our tubes. Fortunately this is easy. A strong solvent like Sweet's 7.62 will remove every trace. Simply run a very wet patch or two through the barrel, wait ten minutes and then dry patch. Warning! Do Not forget about it and leave the strong solvents in the barrel. There have been incidents of these solvents "etching" the barrel when left in. I always like to run a couple of patches of Hoppes Number Nine through the tube after dry patching. I leave that in for a while just in case of burnt on powder residue. Then I repeat the Sweet's, dry patch and Hoppes until my dry patches show no trace whatever of that blue-green jacket fouling. Don't scrub and scrub with a brush, let the solvent do the work.
I am seldom in a hurry so I don't often use the Sweet's. I use Butch's Bore Shine instead. It's a less aggressive solvent that is safe to leave in that expensive barrel. Run a couple of wet patches through and then leave it for a few hours or even overnight. Then dry patch and repeat until we again get no trace of that blue-green. Follow up with a regular gun oil.
Getting the jacket fouling out will eliminate at least half of the potential leading before we even look at the lead bullets.
Next we look at the size of the bullet. Obviously I'm not discussing .45 caliber bullets in a .22. It's important that the bullet be just a thousandth of an inch or two larger than the bore, this keeps the powder gases behind the bullet, where they belong. We have a little leeway here. If the bullet is as much as three or four thou over it seems to swage down just fine. For that matter, unless our alloy is too hard, the kick in the butt from those high pressure gases will slug it up to fit. The proper term for this is obturation, The trouble is, most of the storebought cast bullets are too hard to do this with mild loads. A mistake many handloaders make when shooting storebought cast bullets is going to a lighter load when they get leading. It's counterintuitive but the answer to leading is often to increase the pressure.
There is a simple working mathematical formula that can tell the minimum pressure needed for proper bullet obturation. It requires that we either have a Saeco lead hardness tester or at least know the number that this device gives to the more common lead alloys. The most common commercially cast bullets run a fairly hard alloy, usually the old 85% lead. 5% tin and 10% antimony, this gives an LHT number of around nine or ten. The formula is LHT multiplied by 2,000 + the required pressure, we need a load that gives in the neighborhood of 18 or 20,000 PSI to allow a too-small bullet to slug up. This is important because this is over the allowable pressure for a lot of cartridges and guns. For instance my Cimarron clone of the Colt Single Action Army only allows a maximum average pressure of 14,000 PSI. This means that storebought cast bullets must not be too small because they aren't going to slug up. This is compounded by the fact that the revolver's chamber throats are supposed to be bigger than the bore. In order that the powder gases stay behind the bullet, then, my bullet must be large enough to plug up that chamber. I have two different brands of store-bought cast .45 bullets on hand, Meister and Rucker, both are plenty tight in the barrel, both are too small for the chamber throats. Both are too hard to slug up in those throats meaning I get gas blow by until they're in the barrel proper. There is a very simple way to tell if that bullet is too small for the chamber throat. If we can push it through the cylinder's chamber by finger pressure, it's too small.
Gas blow by is a Bad Thing. It robs the load of power and that hot, high-pressure gas blows the lube out of the groove meaning I've got bare, unlubricated lead going down my barrel. This is why I cast my own bullets. I can size them to fit my particular gun and I can use a soft enough alloy to slug the bullets up at low pressures.
Oddly the suppliers of cast bullets to the handloading trade know that their bullets are cast of an alloy that is too hard for best results in all but full power magnum hunting loads. They know that these magnum hunting loads are less than a quarter of what we actually load. The trouble is that the soft bullets get beat up in shipping and handling. There are a very few commercial casters making soft bullets for the low pressures involved in Cowboy Action Shooting, these bullets are quite a bit more expensive than the hard cast because they have to be carefully packed to avoid damage in shipment. One such supplier is Desperado Cowboy Bullets, LLC.
There are three answers for the handloader that wants those pleasant-shooting low recoil lead bullet loads. Cast your own or buy the more-expensive Cowboy Action bullets. Another answer is the swaged bullets from Hornaday, Speer and Remington. They're available in the most popular calibers, Midway, among others, stocks them. Those swaged bullets are usually a bit more expensive than the cheapest cast bullets, they're quite a bit cheaper than buying those soft-cast.
The third answer is a simple one. Let the barrel lead. Just shoot the cheap bullets and don't worry that the inside of your barrel is looking like a poorly-maintained sewer pipe. It takes quite a bit of leading before accuracy starts to degrade, odds are that you'll be ready to stop shooting before it does, Then, at the end of the shooting session shoot half a box or so of jacketed bullets. The lead will tin itself to those bullet jackets and leave the barrel. How many jacketed bullets it takes to remove all the lead depends on how bad the leading is. Bear in mind that there is no solvent that dissolves lead, not that won't dissolve the barrel. There are many solvents that dissolve jacket fouling. Forget scrubbing the barrel for hours to remove lead, shoot it out.
The shooter with an autoloader seldom has to worry that his store bought cast bullet will be too hard. The shallow rifling in an autoloader's barrel requires a very hard bullet. With only one chamber throat, instead of five or six there is less of a chance that the chamber throat won't match the barrel and, lastly, if the load is stout enough to work the action, chances are it's going to be stout enough to slug up the hard bullets. Working pressures in autoloaders run higher, anyway. While the revolver shooter has to worry that his bullet is too hard, the autoloader must worry that the bullet might be too soft to take the rifling. A too soft bullet in an original Colt .45 ACP will 'strip the rifling', meaning that it won't spin, it will just charge right through and not spin at all. Needless to say the inside of the barrel will be a real mess and accuracy will be nonexistent. It's my understanding that Glock specifically disallows using cast bullets in their handguns and that there have been KABOOMS resulting from such use. The going theory of why this happens is that the working of the cartridge from magazine to chamber scrapes off a tiny bit of lead from the bullet. As this lead builds up in the front of the chamber it eventually results in the gun firing with enough of the back end of the cartridge sticking out that it is unsupported, the cartridge case fails to hold the pressure and we get the KABOOM. I've seen one such gun and the cartridge case, the theory matches the look of both. There was no information on the number of lead bullet rounds were fired before the KABOOM. Avoid lead with Glocks.
Another autoloader that doesn't seem to work with lead alloy bullets is the Heckler and Koch. Here the problem is not KABOOMS but the lack of conventional rifling in the barrel. Instead of regular rifling the barrel is actually a polygon shape and cast bullets don't seem to work well. It's not a matter of safety but accuracy. I know of no serious experimentation with alloys and lubes to try to make cast bullets work in them. I suspect that those who are well-heeled enough to afford an H&K can afford jacketed bullets.
With those exceptions, the humble lead bullet is the way to go. In mild loads it's cheap and easy on recoil and muzzle blast. At the other end of the spectrum a well shaped lead alloy bullet will penetrate more deeply in large game than any expanding bullet. For the most horsepower from your magnum revolver it's a heavy flat-point hard cast bullet loaded to the highest velocity.
Update. I realized that I got ahead of myself and neglected to put the LHT number of some of the other more common bullet allys. Here are a few... One part tin to twenty parts lead is just under six. This is my preferred alloy for those low pressure smokeless powder loads. They'll slug up nicely at just under 12,000 PSI. That's perfect for standard pressure .45 Colt loads and other target loads where recoil and very loud muzzle blast are problems.
Another common ally is one part tin to thirty parts lead...giving a LHT of 2. This is a good alloy for black powder shooters, there is enough tin to help the alloy fill out the bullet in the mold, the main reason we add tin to our bullet metal, yet not so much that the bullet doesn't slug up for proper obturation at those low black powder pressures.
Common wheelweight metal runs about seven or eight on the LHT scale.
One of the harder alloys is linotype with an LHT of ten.
Heat treating common wheelweight runs the LHT number up to 12 or 13. This is hard enough for autoloaders and magnum revolver loads. Heat treating bullets is easy. Get a old cookie sheet, load it up with unlubricated bullets, put them in a 450 degree oven and leave them for about an hour, two hours if there's a large quantity of bullets. Let them cool in the oven and then set them aside for about 24 hours before sizing and lubing. Heat treating bullets made of linotype alloy makes them hard enough to use in rifle loads up to well over 2,000 feet per second if we use a good lube.
Update #2...I know half my links don't work, I can't figure out why. Just google them, I'm tired of fighting with them. Shucks and other colorful comments.
There is a lot of good information about shooting the lead alloy bullet that has almost passed from general knowledge as our grandparents passed from the scene. The first bit of information that has been lost is that cast bullets don't have to lead a barrel, and won't if they're the right size, hardness and properly lubricated. This, of course, assumes that the barrel in question isn't full of rust, pits and tool marks. The first step in our quest to eliminate barrel leading is to remove all traces of jacket fouling from our tubes. Fortunately this is easy. A strong solvent like Sweet's 7.62 will remove every trace. Simply run a very wet patch or two through the barrel, wait ten minutes and then dry patch. Warning! Do Not forget about it and leave the strong solvents in the barrel. There have been incidents of these solvents "etching" the barrel when left in. I always like to run a couple of patches of Hoppes Number Nine through the tube after dry patching. I leave that in for a while just in case of burnt on powder residue. Then I repeat the Sweet's, dry patch and Hoppes until my dry patches show no trace whatever of that blue-green jacket fouling. Don't scrub and scrub with a brush, let the solvent do the work.
I am seldom in a hurry so I don't often use the Sweet's. I use Butch's Bore Shine instead. It's a less aggressive solvent that is safe to leave in that expensive barrel. Run a couple of wet patches through and then leave it for a few hours or even overnight. Then dry patch and repeat until we again get no trace of that blue-green. Follow up with a regular gun oil.
Getting the jacket fouling out will eliminate at least half of the potential leading before we even look at the lead bullets.
Next we look at the size of the bullet. Obviously I'm not discussing .45 caliber bullets in a .22. It's important that the bullet be just a thousandth of an inch or two larger than the bore, this keeps the powder gases behind the bullet, where they belong. We have a little leeway here. If the bullet is as much as three or four thou over it seems to swage down just fine. For that matter, unless our alloy is too hard, the kick in the butt from those high pressure gases will slug it up to fit. The proper term for this is obturation, The trouble is, most of the storebought cast bullets are too hard to do this with mild loads. A mistake many handloaders make when shooting storebought cast bullets is going to a lighter load when they get leading. It's counterintuitive but the answer to leading is often to increase the pressure.
There is a simple working mathematical formula that can tell the minimum pressure needed for proper bullet obturation. It requires that we either have a Saeco lead hardness tester or at least know the number that this device gives to the more common lead alloys. The most common commercially cast bullets run a fairly hard alloy, usually the old 85% lead. 5% tin and 10% antimony, this gives an LHT number of around nine or ten. The formula is LHT multiplied by 2,000 + the required pressure, we need a load that gives in the neighborhood of 18 or 20,000 PSI to allow a too-small bullet to slug up. This is important because this is over the allowable pressure for a lot of cartridges and guns. For instance my Cimarron clone of the Colt Single Action Army only allows a maximum average pressure of 14,000 PSI. This means that storebought cast bullets must not be too small because they aren't going to slug up. This is compounded by the fact that the revolver's chamber throats are supposed to be bigger than the bore. In order that the powder gases stay behind the bullet, then, my bullet must be large enough to plug up that chamber. I have two different brands of store-bought cast .45 bullets on hand, Meister and Rucker, both are plenty tight in the barrel, both are too small for the chamber throats. Both are too hard to slug up in those throats meaning I get gas blow by until they're in the barrel proper. There is a very simple way to tell if that bullet is too small for the chamber throat. If we can push it through the cylinder's chamber by finger pressure, it's too small.
Gas blow by is a Bad Thing. It robs the load of power and that hot, high-pressure gas blows the lube out of the groove meaning I've got bare, unlubricated lead going down my barrel. This is why I cast my own bullets. I can size them to fit my particular gun and I can use a soft enough alloy to slug the bullets up at low pressures.
Oddly the suppliers of cast bullets to the handloading trade know that their bullets are cast of an alloy that is too hard for best results in all but full power magnum hunting loads. They know that these magnum hunting loads are less than a quarter of what we actually load. The trouble is that the soft bullets get beat up in shipping and handling. There are a very few commercial casters making soft bullets for the low pressures involved in Cowboy Action Shooting, these bullets are quite a bit more expensive than the hard cast because they have to be carefully packed to avoid damage in shipment. One such supplier is Desperado Cowboy Bullets, LLC.
There are three answers for the handloader that wants those pleasant-shooting low recoil lead bullet loads. Cast your own or buy the more-expensive Cowboy Action bullets. Another answer is the swaged bullets from Hornaday, Speer and Remington. They're available in the most popular calibers, Midway, among others, stocks them. Those swaged bullets are usually a bit more expensive than the cheapest cast bullets, they're quite a bit cheaper than buying those soft-cast.
The third answer is a simple one. Let the barrel lead. Just shoot the cheap bullets and don't worry that the inside of your barrel is looking like a poorly-maintained sewer pipe. It takes quite a bit of leading before accuracy starts to degrade, odds are that you'll be ready to stop shooting before it does, Then, at the end of the shooting session shoot half a box or so of jacketed bullets. The lead will tin itself to those bullet jackets and leave the barrel. How many jacketed bullets it takes to remove all the lead depends on how bad the leading is. Bear in mind that there is no solvent that dissolves lead, not that won't dissolve the barrel. There are many solvents that dissolve jacket fouling. Forget scrubbing the barrel for hours to remove lead, shoot it out.
The shooter with an autoloader seldom has to worry that his store bought cast bullet will be too hard. The shallow rifling in an autoloader's barrel requires a very hard bullet. With only one chamber throat, instead of five or six there is less of a chance that the chamber throat won't match the barrel and, lastly, if the load is stout enough to work the action, chances are it's going to be stout enough to slug up the hard bullets. Working pressures in autoloaders run higher, anyway. While the revolver shooter has to worry that his bullet is too hard, the autoloader must worry that the bullet might be too soft to take the rifling. A too soft bullet in an original Colt .45 ACP will 'strip the rifling', meaning that it won't spin, it will just charge right through and not spin at all. Needless to say the inside of the barrel will be a real mess and accuracy will be nonexistent. It's my understanding that Glock specifically disallows using cast bullets in their handguns and that there have been KABOOMS resulting from such use. The going theory of why this happens is that the working of the cartridge from magazine to chamber scrapes off a tiny bit of lead from the bullet. As this lead builds up in the front of the chamber it eventually results in the gun firing with enough of the back end of the cartridge sticking out that it is unsupported, the cartridge case fails to hold the pressure and we get the KABOOM. I've seen one such gun and the cartridge case, the theory matches the look of both. There was no information on the number of lead bullet rounds were fired before the KABOOM. Avoid lead with Glocks.
Another autoloader that doesn't seem to work with lead alloy bullets is the Heckler and Koch. Here the problem is not KABOOMS but the lack of conventional rifling in the barrel. Instead of regular rifling the barrel is actually a polygon shape and cast bullets don't seem to work well. It's not a matter of safety but accuracy. I know of no serious experimentation with alloys and lubes to try to make cast bullets work in them. I suspect that those who are well-heeled enough to afford an H&K can afford jacketed bullets.
With those exceptions, the humble lead bullet is the way to go. In mild loads it's cheap and easy on recoil and muzzle blast. At the other end of the spectrum a well shaped lead alloy bullet will penetrate more deeply in large game than any expanding bullet. For the most horsepower from your magnum revolver it's a heavy flat-point hard cast bullet loaded to the highest velocity.
Update. I realized that I got ahead of myself and neglected to put the LHT number of some of the other more common bullet allys. Here are a few... One part tin to twenty parts lead is just under six. This is my preferred alloy for those low pressure smokeless powder loads. They'll slug up nicely at just under 12,000 PSI. That's perfect for standard pressure .45 Colt loads and other target loads where recoil and very loud muzzle blast are problems.
Another common ally is one part tin to thirty parts lead...giving a LHT of 2. This is a good alloy for black powder shooters, there is enough tin to help the alloy fill out the bullet in the mold, the main reason we add tin to our bullet metal, yet not so much that the bullet doesn't slug up for proper obturation at those low black powder pressures.
Common wheelweight metal runs about seven or eight on the LHT scale.
One of the harder alloys is linotype with an LHT of ten.
Heat treating common wheelweight runs the LHT number up to 12 or 13. This is hard enough for autoloaders and magnum revolver loads. Heat treating bullets is easy. Get a old cookie sheet, load it up with unlubricated bullets, put them in a 450 degree oven and leave them for about an hour, two hours if there's a large quantity of bullets. Let them cool in the oven and then set them aside for about 24 hours before sizing and lubing. Heat treating bullets made of linotype alloy makes them hard enough to use in rifle loads up to well over 2,000 feet per second if we use a good lube.
Update #2...I know half my links don't work, I can't figure out why. Just google them, I'm tired of fighting with them. Shucks and other colorful comments.
Monday, June 20, 2005
Too Angry To Write
I've been reading and hearing about the "terrible abuses" That the poor innocent little lambs we scooped up for no reason and put in Gitmo have been subjected to. It's had me so angry that I've been unable to post anything I've written because of the profanity and what would be considered threats.
One of the reasons I'm so angry is that the Left, exemplified by this Dick(less) Durbin feller is endangering my family. At once he tries to tie the hands of our law enforcement, military and intel people while he aids the Jihadi recruitment and slanders not only the people doing the interrogations down there but everyone who wears, or has worn, Uncle's suit.
I'm tired of this. I'm tired of hearing about the Geneva Convention rules on POWs. These are not POWs, they're Unlawful Combatants. Under the Geneva Convention rules they have a right to a last cigarette, a blindfold and a stout wall to stand before. Instead they get better living conditions, and certainly better food, than the guys in the rifle platoons serving in Iraq or the Stan. They certainly get more religious freedom that an American kid in public school.
I don't care that some terrorist scumbag gets too hot or too cold. I don't care that the music is too loud. I don't even care if some scantily clad woman invades their personal space. (Pick Me! Torture Me like that!) I would have a difficult time caring if every interrogation session began with the interrogator gouging out the detainee's left eye and eating it like a cherry tomato just to show he's serious. I'm not advocating this, mind you, after all I don't know where these eyeballs have been. I'd hate for our people to get sick.
These Lefty's hatred of the Bush Administration and their lust for regained political power are so out of control that they are willing to have us lose this war in order that George Bush look bad. If we lose this war American citizens will die, not just overseas but here. That's my family they're willing to sacrifice. I won't forget this come election day. More, if by their efforts the Lefties succeed in tying the hands of our intel, law enforcement and military people and my family members get killed or maimed I might just go hunting.
One of the reasons I'm so angry is that the Left, exemplified by this Dick(less) Durbin feller is endangering my family. At once he tries to tie the hands of our law enforcement, military and intel people while he aids the Jihadi recruitment and slanders not only the people doing the interrogations down there but everyone who wears, or has worn, Uncle's suit.
I'm tired of this. I'm tired of hearing about the Geneva Convention rules on POWs. These are not POWs, they're Unlawful Combatants. Under the Geneva Convention rules they have a right to a last cigarette, a blindfold and a stout wall to stand before. Instead they get better living conditions, and certainly better food, than the guys in the rifle platoons serving in Iraq or the Stan. They certainly get more religious freedom that an American kid in public school.
I don't care that some terrorist scumbag gets too hot or too cold. I don't care that the music is too loud. I don't even care if some scantily clad woman invades their personal space. (Pick Me! Torture Me like that!) I would have a difficult time caring if every interrogation session began with the interrogator gouging out the detainee's left eye and eating it like a cherry tomato just to show he's serious. I'm not advocating this, mind you, after all I don't know where these eyeballs have been. I'd hate for our people to get sick.
These Lefty's hatred of the Bush Administration and their lust for regained political power are so out of control that they are willing to have us lose this war in order that George Bush look bad. If we lose this war American citizens will die, not just overseas but here. That's my family they're willing to sacrifice. I won't forget this come election day. More, if by their efforts the Lefties succeed in tying the hands of our intel, law enforcement and military people and my family members get killed or maimed I might just go hunting.
Saturday, June 18, 2005
Thursday, June 16, 2005
Titegroup and LilGun, Two Powders From Hodgdon
I've been fooling with a couple of Hodgdon's newer canister powders for the handloader and here are my impressions.
Hodgdon's LilGun is a powder designed for loading the .410 shotgun, some of the smaller rifle cartridges and, especially magnum revolver ammo. I haven't messed with the .410 bore shotgun since before I started shaving so my work with this powder has been in the .357 Magnum.
LilGun is a double based powder containing both nitrocellulose and nitroglycerine, it is about the same burning rate as H110, a little slower according to one burn rate chart from Hodgdon and a little faster than H110 according to Ramshot's burn rate chart. This discrepancy in those burn rate charts shows the folly of trying to determine load data simply by looking at the charts.
Fans of high velocity revolver ammo will swear by this powder. Using Hodgdon's max listed load of 18.0 grains of LilGun behind the Hornaday 158 grain XTP hollowpoint I was able to chronograph over 1400 fps (feet per second) out of my Ruger GP100's six inch tube. This is a full 150 fps gain over any other powder I've tried in all the years I've been messing around with the .357.
This same load clocked over 1900 fps in my 18.5 inch barreled Marlin 1894C Carbine. Just because I could I drove up to a friend's in Lawton Oklahoma, this friend has one of those pricey Oehler Ballistic Laboratories, we put a strain gauge on my carbine and tested the pressure. Here I'll confess to exceeding Hodgdon's listed maximum load , something I do not recommend.
I did it because I had access to pressure testing equipment, we loaded the ammo right there and took extreme care. We worked up in half grain steps, we were trying to break the magic 2,000 fps barrier with the carbine. We did it though the pressure was some 3,000 pounds per square inch over the SAAMI maximum. I won't give the data nor will I use that load for general shooting. My carbine digested it with no trouble but accuracy went to that hot place the preacher warned me about. Stick to the listed max. For another thing it was a real pain working with that much powder, the cases got so full it was difficult to start the bullet.
One odd thing about this powder is that pressure and velocity fell off when we tried sparking the load with Winchester small pistol magnum primers. Extreme spreads and standard deviations also increased with the mag primers. At least in my shootin' irons the standard small pistol primer gives higher velocity and better consistency. Please don't ask me why. Starline brass was used in all the initial tests, later repeated with Federal brass with negligible differences.
Recoil in that light carbine is brisk. Not painful by any means but noticeably higher than with most other loads I've used.
On the other end of the spectrum is Hodgdon's Titegroup. As the name implies, this powder is for lighter target loads. I've tried it with lead alloy bullets in .38 Special, .357 Mag and .45 Colt. In the .38 and .357 I've used it with both my own home-cast 158 grain Lee Semiwadcutters and the Speer swaged 148 grain hollow based wadcutters. In the .45 Colt I've only used it in my home cast 250 grain round nosed flat points, again out of a Lee mold. I confess to loving the Lee molds, not only are they the most inexpensive on the market but the aluminum blocks are light enough that there isn't a lot of fatigue during a long casting session. Also, unlike the other brands on the market you buy the double cavity mold and it comes with the handles already on. Other, unnamed molds (cough, Lyman, cough), the durned handles cost more than the whole setup from Lee.
I haven't bothered setting up the Chronograph working with Titegroup, I'm not particularly interested in the velocity of these loads. They get to the target before I get bored waiting around and they have enough bohemous to fight their way through a piece of target paper and the backing, that's all I'm interested in.
What does interest me is that Titegroup is both clean shooting and economical. In the .38 a load of 3.0 grains behind the 148 grain wadcutter does the trick. That's well over 2,000 rounds out of a pound of powder. I like that. The same charge works fine with that bullet in .357 brass.
I went up a half grain using the semiwadcutter bullets just because there is so much more airspace in the case with the bullets not being seated so deeply. I'm not sure I really needed too but once the powder measure was set I haven't bothered changing it. Again, the same charge worked fine in both the .38 and the .357.
Accuracy in both the .38 and the .357s is close enough to my best loads with other powders that whether one shoots better than the other depends more on how I'm shooting on a given day than on the load.
The .38s I shot this load in were our old Colt Police Positive Special with a four inch barrel and my wife's S&W Ladysmith Model 60. The .357s were the Ruger six inch GP100 and my little three inch tubed Ruger SP101, my preferred carry gun. I haven't tried it in my Marlin Carbine but I suspect it'd be a superb small game load.
In the .45 Colt I went with just under Hodgdon's max load of 6.2 grains, my measure was throwing 6.0 and I quit fooling with the adjustments. My Cimarron Arms copy of the Colt Single Action Army shot more accurately with this load than anything else I've tried to date and that includes the two boxes of factory fodder that I put through it while waiting for my dies and mold to come from Midway. I've loaded Alliant's Unique, Bullseye and Red Dot as well as Accurate's Number Five and Hodgdon's Universal Clays, Titegroup beat them all as far as accuracy goes in my .45.
Hodgdon claims that Titegroup is position insensitive, that it burns consistently regardless of where that little charge is in those fairly large .38 and .357 cases and the cavernous .45 Colt case. To check out that claim I set up a sandbag rest on a fifty yard bench Using both the Cimarron .45 and the GP100 I shot five groups from each, elevating the muzzle between shots and then gently getting on the bags so as to keep the powder charge near the primer. I then fired groups without elevating the muzzle. I'm not a good enough shot to tell the difference. I then fired a couple-three groups elevating the muzzle on one shot and holding the gun down on the next so that the powder charge would be by the bullet one time and the primer the next. There was still no significant difference. It will take a better shot than I am to prove Hodgdon wrong.
The downside to Titegroup is that the charges take so little room in the case that one could easily double or even triple-charge a load. The answer is to take that extra step and shine a small flashlight down every case in the loading block once the cases are charged.
So, there you have it. Titegroup is replacing Bullseye, Red Dot, 700X, Clays and Universal Clays for my light target loads and LilGun is replacing H110, 2400, Blue Dot, 4227, 800X and Accurate Number Nine for my heavy loads. I'll keep some Unique around just for my medium power woodsloafing loads, just because. I'm sure my insurance agent will sleep better at night knowing that I'm replacing eleven different powders with three.
Update 60/18/05: Having slept on it I thought I should elaborate a bit on what happened when we deliberatly went over the Hodgdon maximum load for LilGun in the .357 Mag. We went up in half grain steps and there was very little change in pressure and velocity the first couple of steps, the pressure stayed under SAMMI Max with a comfortable margin, but little or no gain in velocity. Then, in one half-grain step the pressure went from well under to right at that max. The next step up went to an average of 3,000 over with the highest peak pressure of the test at over 7,000 over max.
In a future carnival I'll write some on what the late P. O. Ackley, one of the gurus of America's golden age of wildcatting called the "balance point" of powders, the point at which the increases in powder charge stops giving easily-predictable increases in pressure and velocity. There is a way, using a chronograph, to find that balance point without having pressure testing equipment. It's too long to include in this post so I'll save it for another time.
Hodgdon's LilGun is a powder designed for loading the .410 shotgun, some of the smaller rifle cartridges and, especially magnum revolver ammo. I haven't messed with the .410 bore shotgun since before I started shaving so my work with this powder has been in the .357 Magnum.
LilGun is a double based powder containing both nitrocellulose and nitroglycerine, it is about the same burning rate as H110, a little slower according to one burn rate chart from Hodgdon and a little faster than H110 according to Ramshot's burn rate chart. This discrepancy in those burn rate charts shows the folly of trying to determine load data simply by looking at the charts.
Fans of high velocity revolver ammo will swear by this powder. Using Hodgdon's max listed load of 18.0 grains of LilGun behind the Hornaday 158 grain XTP hollowpoint I was able to chronograph over 1400 fps (feet per second) out of my Ruger GP100's six inch tube. This is a full 150 fps gain over any other powder I've tried in all the years I've been messing around with the .357.
This same load clocked over 1900 fps in my 18.5 inch barreled Marlin 1894C Carbine. Just because I could I drove up to a friend's in Lawton Oklahoma, this friend has one of those pricey Oehler Ballistic Laboratories, we put a strain gauge on my carbine and tested the pressure. Here I'll confess to exceeding Hodgdon's listed maximum load , something I do not recommend.
I did it because I had access to pressure testing equipment, we loaded the ammo right there and took extreme care. We worked up in half grain steps, we were trying to break the magic 2,000 fps barrier with the carbine. We did it though the pressure was some 3,000 pounds per square inch over the SAAMI maximum. I won't give the data nor will I use that load for general shooting. My carbine digested it with no trouble but accuracy went to that hot place the preacher warned me about. Stick to the listed max. For another thing it was a real pain working with that much powder, the cases got so full it was difficult to start the bullet.
One odd thing about this powder is that pressure and velocity fell off when we tried sparking the load with Winchester small pistol magnum primers. Extreme spreads and standard deviations also increased with the mag primers. At least in my shootin' irons the standard small pistol primer gives higher velocity and better consistency. Please don't ask me why. Starline brass was used in all the initial tests, later repeated with Federal brass with negligible differences.
Recoil in that light carbine is brisk. Not painful by any means but noticeably higher than with most other loads I've used.
On the other end of the spectrum is Hodgdon's Titegroup. As the name implies, this powder is for lighter target loads. I've tried it with lead alloy bullets in .38 Special, .357 Mag and .45 Colt. In the .38 and .357 I've used it with both my own home-cast 158 grain Lee Semiwadcutters and the Speer swaged 148 grain hollow based wadcutters. In the .45 Colt I've only used it in my home cast 250 grain round nosed flat points, again out of a Lee mold. I confess to loving the Lee molds, not only are they the most inexpensive on the market but the aluminum blocks are light enough that there isn't a lot of fatigue during a long casting session. Also, unlike the other brands on the market you buy the double cavity mold and it comes with the handles already on. Other, unnamed molds (cough, Lyman, cough), the durned handles cost more than the whole setup from Lee.
I haven't bothered setting up the Chronograph working with Titegroup, I'm not particularly interested in the velocity of these loads. They get to the target before I get bored waiting around and they have enough bohemous to fight their way through a piece of target paper and the backing, that's all I'm interested in.
What does interest me is that Titegroup is both clean shooting and economical. In the .38 a load of 3.0 grains behind the 148 grain wadcutter does the trick. That's well over 2,000 rounds out of a pound of powder. I like that. The same charge works fine with that bullet in .357 brass.
I went up a half grain using the semiwadcutter bullets just because there is so much more airspace in the case with the bullets not being seated so deeply. I'm not sure I really needed too but once the powder measure was set I haven't bothered changing it. Again, the same charge worked fine in both the .38 and the .357.
Accuracy in both the .38 and the .357s is close enough to my best loads with other powders that whether one shoots better than the other depends more on how I'm shooting on a given day than on the load.
The .38s I shot this load in were our old Colt Police Positive Special with a four inch barrel and my wife's S&W Ladysmith Model 60. The .357s were the Ruger six inch GP100 and my little three inch tubed Ruger SP101, my preferred carry gun. I haven't tried it in my Marlin Carbine but I suspect it'd be a superb small game load.
In the .45 Colt I went with just under Hodgdon's max load of 6.2 grains, my measure was throwing 6.0 and I quit fooling with the adjustments. My Cimarron Arms copy of the Colt Single Action Army shot more accurately with this load than anything else I've tried to date and that includes the two boxes of factory fodder that I put through it while waiting for my dies and mold to come from Midway. I've loaded Alliant's Unique, Bullseye and Red Dot as well as Accurate's Number Five and Hodgdon's Universal Clays, Titegroup beat them all as far as accuracy goes in my .45.
Hodgdon claims that Titegroup is position insensitive, that it burns consistently regardless of where that little charge is in those fairly large .38 and .357 cases and the cavernous .45 Colt case. To check out that claim I set up a sandbag rest on a fifty yard bench Using both the Cimarron .45 and the GP100 I shot five groups from each, elevating the muzzle between shots and then gently getting on the bags so as to keep the powder charge near the primer. I then fired groups without elevating the muzzle. I'm not a good enough shot to tell the difference. I then fired a couple-three groups elevating the muzzle on one shot and holding the gun down on the next so that the powder charge would be by the bullet one time and the primer the next. There was still no significant difference. It will take a better shot than I am to prove Hodgdon wrong.
The downside to Titegroup is that the charges take so little room in the case that one could easily double or even triple-charge a load. The answer is to take that extra step and shine a small flashlight down every case in the loading block once the cases are charged.
So, there you have it. Titegroup is replacing Bullseye, Red Dot, 700X, Clays and Universal Clays for my light target loads and LilGun is replacing H110, 2400, Blue Dot, 4227, 800X and Accurate Number Nine for my heavy loads. I'll keep some Unique around just for my medium power woodsloafing loads, just because. I'm sure my insurance agent will sleep better at night knowing that I'm replacing eleven different powders with three.
Update 60/18/05: Having slept on it I thought I should elaborate a bit on what happened when we deliberatly went over the Hodgdon maximum load for LilGun in the .357 Mag. We went up in half grain steps and there was very little change in pressure and velocity the first couple of steps, the pressure stayed under SAMMI Max with a comfortable margin, but little or no gain in velocity. Then, in one half-grain step the pressure went from well under to right at that max. The next step up went to an average of 3,000 over with the highest peak pressure of the test at over 7,000 over max.
In a future carnival I'll write some on what the late P. O. Ackley, one of the gurus of America's golden age of wildcatting called the "balance point" of powders, the point at which the increases in powder charge stops giving easily-predictable increases in pressure and velocity. There is a way, using a chronograph, to find that balance point without having pressure testing equipment. It's too long to include in this post so I'll save it for another time.
Wednesday, June 08, 2005
Young Men And Women Die
A letter from an Air Force surgeon in Iraq explained the First Rule of War. Get a couple of tissues and go here. I'll wait. (update: seems you have to scroll down to 'Letter From A Doctor in Iraq)
Back? Nose blown and eyes wiped? Yeah the cigar smoke is tough in this little room, sorry. Lemme light those candles, they help some.
Are you struck by the effort those Docs , Nurses and other personals expended before they even looked at the obviously nonsurvivable head wound? No one in that trauma center OR even thought about half stepping, a young man was badly injured by an IED and they were going to do everything possible. They did, they ran the IVs and the ventilator, the X-Rays and ultrasound and checked for other wounds. Then they ran up against Rule Number One. Young Men and Women Die.
Rule Number Two was staring them in the face...Surgeons Cannot Change the First Rule. They've sure modified it, though. They're saving lives. Routinely. They're saving people that, in my war, would have been set aside in Triage with the strongest Nurses and Corpsmen charged with holding their hands while they died. It starts at the point of the injury. All of our Servicemen and women get basic first aid training with a significant number of them getting a higher level called Combat Lifesaver training. Then there's 'Doc', the Medic, usually one per platoon in my day with a few extras for when platoons are sent out as squads in different directions. There are the crews of the Medevac Helos, Dustoff. Everyone wearing Uncle's Suit goes out knowing that if their luck runs sour Dustoff will come. Bad weather? Dustoff comes anyway. Shooting? Dustoff comes with a couple friends, Apaches or Sea Cobras to force the bad guys to keep their heads down for a minute. Once Dustoff comes the trained Medics in the crew start work right then, stabilizing the injured soldier and, as importantly, radioing the hospital with all the info they can get, all while the pilots are firewalling the throttles and blowing on the windshield to get that extra tenth of an MPH.
Back at the Base the Servicemembers having nothing at all to do with the hospital are still involved. Let a whole bunch of people have a Bad Day at the same time and watch the line form at the blood bank.
Young Men and Women Die. It's not for lack of trying.
Hat tip: Mudville Gazette
Back? Nose blown and eyes wiped? Yeah the cigar smoke is tough in this little room, sorry. Lemme light those candles, they help some.
Are you struck by the effort those Docs , Nurses and other personals expended before they even looked at the obviously nonsurvivable head wound? No one in that trauma center OR even thought about half stepping, a young man was badly injured by an IED and they were going to do everything possible. They did, they ran the IVs and the ventilator, the X-Rays and ultrasound and checked for other wounds. Then they ran up against Rule Number One. Young Men and Women Die.
Rule Number Two was staring them in the face...Surgeons Cannot Change the First Rule. They've sure modified it, though. They're saving lives. Routinely. They're saving people that, in my war, would have been set aside in Triage with the strongest Nurses and Corpsmen charged with holding their hands while they died. It starts at the point of the injury. All of our Servicemen and women get basic first aid training with a significant number of them getting a higher level called Combat Lifesaver training. Then there's 'Doc', the Medic, usually one per platoon in my day with a few extras for when platoons are sent out as squads in different directions. There are the crews of the Medevac Helos, Dustoff. Everyone wearing Uncle's Suit goes out knowing that if their luck runs sour Dustoff will come. Bad weather? Dustoff comes anyway. Shooting? Dustoff comes with a couple friends, Apaches or Sea Cobras to force the bad guys to keep their heads down for a minute. Once Dustoff comes the trained Medics in the crew start work right then, stabilizing the injured soldier and, as importantly, radioing the hospital with all the info they can get, all while the pilots are firewalling the throttles and blowing on the windshield to get that extra tenth of an MPH.
Back at the Base the Servicemembers having nothing at all to do with the hospital are still involved. Let a whole bunch of people have a Bad Day at the same time and watch the line form at the blood bank.
Young Men and Women Die. It's not for lack of trying.
Hat tip: Mudville Gazette
Monday, June 06, 2005
June The Sixth, 1944 And 2005.
There is quite a little difference in sixty-one years as to how the West reacts to an existential threat. By 1944 the War had gone on for some time, the then version of "Shock and Awe" was resulting in the wholesale bombing of enemy cities.
A combination of legitimate fears of sabotage and espionage and fear for the safety of Japanese-Americans, both citizen and non-citizen, plus some overblown fear for the same things had caused the wholesale internment of those folks. There was also the somewhat more selective internment of Germans and Italians, both citizen and non-citizen. Troublesome Americans were dealt with, extra-legally, most often by locking them up in mental hospitals.
The Invasion of Normandy caused more American and British casualties, KIA, WIA, MIA and captured than we've lost in this entire war, so far. In one day.
Today we're quite different, it seems. Instead of interning anyone who might be an enemy we seem to not only welcome them but to give them a veto over the conduct of this war. In my Dad's War the losing Presidential Candidate, Wendell Wilkie, toured the world as a representative of Franklin Roosevelt both reporting back information and rallying the troops and civilian workers. We see what the losing Presidential Candidates of this new era are doing.
We are fighting the most 'humane' war in history, in large part because of the incredible advances in precision munitions coupled with the superb training and skill of our professional military. That's the tactical end, we no longer have to carpet bomb a whole city to hit one target, nor must we slaughter an entire regiment to render it combat-ineffective. An equally large part of why we're fighting this war so delicately is to keep the vast majority of the billion and a half Muslims in this world on the sidelines. The hope, forlorn as it is, is that the changes we're effecting in Afghanistan and Iraq will cause a change in the dynamic of the entire Muslim world. This change, if successful, will prevent a wider war, the West against all Islam.
I've never been really all that sanguine about the chances of winning this war of civilizations by finesse, I've always thought that the chances of avoiding this huge war by fighting a couple of small wars to be somewhere in the range of four or five to one. Still, I've supported the attempt, wholeheartedly. If it works we avoid a war that will make the Hitler-Tojo fracas look like an argument among Kindergartners, if it doesn't work we'll have important land bases and seaports in in the region where we'll be fighting.
This is what angers me so much about the whole Gitmo, Abby-Grabby, Koran-desecration frenzy. It's not just the fact that the whole thing is overblown and being used selectively to beat the Bush Administration. It's not that it puts our people in more danger. It's that we are being forced into this wider war by the very people who claim to be in favor of peace.
Each day, as I read the news, I grow more convinced that we will be in this wider war within a decade or so.
A combination of legitimate fears of sabotage and espionage and fear for the safety of Japanese-Americans, both citizen and non-citizen, plus some overblown fear for the same things had caused the wholesale internment of those folks. There was also the somewhat more selective internment of Germans and Italians, both citizen and non-citizen. Troublesome Americans were dealt with, extra-legally, most often by locking them up in mental hospitals.
The Invasion of Normandy caused more American and British casualties, KIA, WIA, MIA and captured than we've lost in this entire war, so far. In one day.
Today we're quite different, it seems. Instead of interning anyone who might be an enemy we seem to not only welcome them but to give them a veto over the conduct of this war. In my Dad's War the losing Presidential Candidate, Wendell Wilkie, toured the world as a representative of Franklin Roosevelt both reporting back information and rallying the troops and civilian workers. We see what the losing Presidential Candidates of this new era are doing.
We are fighting the most 'humane' war in history, in large part because of the incredible advances in precision munitions coupled with the superb training and skill of our professional military. That's the tactical end, we no longer have to carpet bomb a whole city to hit one target, nor must we slaughter an entire regiment to render it combat-ineffective. An equally large part of why we're fighting this war so delicately is to keep the vast majority of the billion and a half Muslims in this world on the sidelines. The hope, forlorn as it is, is that the changes we're effecting in Afghanistan and Iraq will cause a change in the dynamic of the entire Muslim world. This change, if successful, will prevent a wider war, the West against all Islam.
I've never been really all that sanguine about the chances of winning this war of civilizations by finesse, I've always thought that the chances of avoiding this huge war by fighting a couple of small wars to be somewhere in the range of four or five to one. Still, I've supported the attempt, wholeheartedly. If it works we avoid a war that will make the Hitler-Tojo fracas look like an argument among Kindergartners, if it doesn't work we'll have important land bases and seaports in in the region where we'll be fighting.
This is what angers me so much about the whole Gitmo, Abby-Grabby, Koran-desecration frenzy. It's not just the fact that the whole thing is overblown and being used selectively to beat the Bush Administration. It's not that it puts our people in more danger. It's that we are being forced into this wider war by the very people who claim to be in favor of peace.
Each day, as I read the news, I grow more convinced that we will be in this wider war within a decade or so.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)